Family of soldier killed in IRA bomb denied legal aid

The aftermath at the Horse and Groom pub in Guildford, Surrey, where an IRA bomb attack killed four soldiers and a civilian and injured dozens more.
The aftermath at the Horse and Groom pub in Guildford, Surrey, where an IRA bomb attack killed four soldiers and a civilian and injured dozens more.
Share this article

The denial of legal aid for the family of a young female soldier killed in the Guildford pub bombings has been described as a “travesty”.

Private Ann Hamilton, 19, was one of five people killed by the IRA bombs which devastated two pubs in the Surrey town on October 5, 1974.

Private Caroline Slater, 19, Guardsmen John Hunter, 18, and William Forsyth, 17, of the Scots Guards, and a 21-year-old civilian, Paul Craig, were also killed, while 65 others were injured.

The inquest into the atrocity was suspended in 1975 following the conviction of Gerry Conlon, Paddy Armstrong, Paul Hill and Carole Richardson, known as the Guildford Four.

Their convictions, along with the Maguire Seven, were later quashed.

Earlier this year, the senior coroner for Surrey ordered the original inquest into the bombings to be resumed.

However the Legal Aid Agency in London has denied an application by Ms Hamilton’s family to allow them legal representation at the inquest.

The refusal follows a battle by the families of the victims of the Birmingham pub bombings to secure legal representation in the recent Birmingham inquest, following four years of pro bono representation by the KRW law firm and counsel on their behalf.

Christopher Stanley of KRW said the Hamilton family is “effectively being excluded” from participating in the inquest.

“Again, a family have been excluded from effectively participating into the inquest into the death of their loved one whilst the state agencies - the police, the MoD - have legal representation at taxpayers’ expense,” he said.

“This will be a long and complex process of investigation.

“We will make representations to both the Lord Chancellor and the Home Secretary, but unless the matter of public funding can be resolved or reformed then the family of Ann Hamilton will not be able to engage with this process, which will be a further injustice.”

Kevin Winters of KRW added: “Our firm cannot sustain pro bono assistance in this matter following our commitment to the Birmingham families.

“We have got to the stage of assisting the family of Ann Hamilton and Yvonne Tagg (a survivor of the blasts) and through our representations we have secured the resumption of the Guildford pub bombings’ 1974 inquest.

“There is now a long process of disclosure of material and determining the scope of this investigation.”