May’s deal is worse than staying in EU, says Raab

Brexit Secretary Dominic Raab
Brexit Secretary Dominic Raab

Former Brexit secretary Dominic Raab has hit out at Theresa May’s withdrawal deal, branding it worse than remaining in the EU.

The prominent Leave backer said the agreement would see the UK bound by rules it had no control over.

Asked if the PM’s deal was worse than remaining in the bloc, Mr Raab told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “I’m not going to advocate staying in the EU.

“But, if you just presented me terms, this deal or EU membership, because we would effectively be bound by the same rules but without the control or voice over them, yes, I think this would be even worse than that.”

Downing Street insisted that Mrs May does not share her former Brexit secretary’s assessment.

Asked whether the Prime Minister believed that it would be better for the UK to stay in the EU than accept her deal, a Number 10 spokeswoman said: “Categorically no.”

The spokeswoman added: “This deal delivers on the vote of the British people by taking back control of our money, our laws and our borders, it ends free movement once and for all and it will protect jobs with a deal which is good for the economy.”

Mr Raab said the current agreement was unlikely to be passed by the Commons, and that ministers should contemplate leaving without one, saying: “We will, I think, inevitably see Parliament vote this deal down.

“And then I think some of those other alternatives will need to come into play.”

The former Brexit secretary said the UK would not have to pay the bulk of its £39 billion “divorce bill” if it quit the bloc without a deal.

Mr Raab’s comments came as Mrs May was warned she faces a battle to reach a final agreement on Brexit as she prepares for a special summit of European Union leaders.

Ahead of Sunday’s gathering, Spanish premier Pedro Sanchez demanded last-minute changes to the deal despite Mrs May’s efforts to win him round.

The Prime Minister will head to Brussels on Saturday for eve-of-summit talks with Jean-Claude Juncker knowing that she also faces an uphill task in Westminster to persuade her own MPs to back her deal.

Mrs May declared that final agreement on Brexit is “within our grasp” following a breakthrough on future relations between the UK and European Union on Thursday.

But she endured a bruising session in the House of Commons as critics lined up to condemn both the divorce deal contained in the Withdrawal Agreement and the aspirations for a close future relationship in the Political Declaration.

And, at the EU level, a major obstacle remains in the form of Madrid’s continued concerns about Gibraltar, with Mr Sanchez vowing to “defend the interests of Spain”.

Mrs May said she spoke to Mr Sanchez on Wednesday night and was “confident on Sunday that we’ll be able to agree a deal that delivers for the whole UK family, including Gibraltar”.

But in a late-night tweet on Thursday Mr Sanchez said: “After my conversation with Theresa May, our positions remain far away.

“My Government will always defend the interests of Spain. If there are no changes, we will veto Brexit.”

Mr Sanchez cannot “veto Brexit” or the Withdrawal Agreement, but a refusal to co-operate will sour the atmosphere at a summit where leaders of the 27 remaining EU members were aiming for consensus.

Marco Aguiriano, Spain’s state secretary for European affairs, said Madrid needs “guarantees we can go on with this model”.

“We are asking for an article that is put on the table to be included in the Political Declaration on the future relations,” he told the BBC.

Downing Street said it was “not aware” of any moves to add any appendix or addendum to the Withdrawal Agreement to deal with other nations’ concerns over issues including Gibraltar or fishing.

A spokeswoman said: “The Withdrawal Agreement isn’t being reopened.”

Chief Minister of Gibraltar Fabian Picardo criticised Spain’s stance.

He told the BBC: “Spain doesn’t need an article in the treaties, the future declaration, or indeed the withdrawal agreement, to bring Gibraltar to the table.

“Gibraltar has demonstrated that we actually want a direct engagement with Spain on issues.

“Spain is the physical and geographical gateway to Europe for Gibraltar. We recognise that and there is absolutely no need for us to be vetoed into being brought to the table.”

Mr Picardo added: “Anybody who says my political view, my political prospectus is that we should drive over this cliff like a political Thelma and Louise isn’t thinking about the best interests of the people of the United Kingdom or Gibraltar.”

Education Secretary Damian Hinds said he believed support for the Prime Minister’s Brexit deal would grow in Parliament as MPs considered the alternatives.

Asked on the Today programme whether Mrs May could win a vote on her deal now, he said: “You say ... if a vote were taken today. The vote isn’t going to be taken today. We are going to have days of debate in Parliament, there is going to be a lot of debate and discussion in the country.

“We will reflect on what is being proposed. That’s what MPs are for.”

He warned: “If we weren’t to pass this deal, I think it becomes rather unpredictable what happens next. There is a risk on the one hand beyond that of no Brexit at all - and there are people trying to thwart Brexit - and there is also a risk of no deal. Neither of those is attractive.”