Doug Beattie: Perceptions of bias are a fact of life in N Ireland

The Heights Bar at Loughinisland in Co Down, which was attacked by loyalists in 1994, leaving six men dead. Photo: PA/PA Wire
The Heights Bar at Loughinisland in Co Down, which was attacked by loyalists in 1994, leaving six men dead. Photo: PA/PA Wire
Share this article

Mr Justice McCloskey’s decision to step aside from the case relating to the report on the Loughinisland massacre, even though the legal test has not been satisfied, raises serious questions for the administration of justice in Northern Ireland.

The issue arose because he had previously been involved in a similar case against the Police Ombudsman’s office in 2002 and as a result, it was argued that there was a potential public perception of bias.

Letters to Editor

Letters to Editor

We live in a country that still has deep divisions and allegations and perceptions of bias are an inevitable fact of life.

The fact that Barra McGrory previously represented senior Sinn Fein figures proved no barrier to his later appointment as Director of Public Prosecutions and indeed he is now representing the Ombudsman in the very case from which Mr Justice McCloskey has just recused himself.

Many people will be forgiven for asking why the perception of bias in our legal system only seems to apply to those who have previously acted for the police and not to those who have previously acted for republicans.

Doug Beattie MC MLA, Ulster Unionist justice spokesperson

Ben Lowry: Judge standing aside in Loughinisland is astonishing

Jim Allister: If anyone should be considering their position, it’s the Ombudsman

The full 8,000 word judgment from Mr Justice McCloskey

(Click here for a shorter report on the ruling)