Compensating NI’s child abuse survivors ‘could cost £30m’

Father Brendan Smyth was a notorious paedophile priest.
Father Brendan Smyth was a notorious paedophile priest.

The bill for compensating survivors of child abuse in Northern Ireland could run to £30 million, campaigners have warned.

Some 524 victims could be eligible to make claims over their treatment in institutions from 1922-1995, including at the notorious Kincora Boys’ Home in Belfast and by paedophile priest Brendan Smyth.

William McGrath was a prolific child abuser at the Kincora Boys' Home

William McGrath was a prolific child abuser at the Kincora Boys' Home

Campaigners are urging the Executive to agree to a special redress scheme, with basic payments starting at £10,000, to avoid lengthy, traumatic and expensive civil actions in the courts.

They said it could save £10m off the final bill. Margaret McGuckin of Survivors and Victims of Institutional Abuse, said: “It is now up to ministers to deliver.

“Redress is a practical way for Government and others to say sorry for how badly they let us down as children. We suffered then and have suffered the consequences through our lives ever since – psychological damage and lost opportunities. We shouldn’t have to suffer on into our old age as well.”

The chairman of the Historical Institutional Abuse Inquiry, Sir Anthony Hart, is due to report to Stormont ministers in January on 157 days of public hearings and evidence from 392 witnesses.

Survivors of abuse are to take their campaign for a suitable redress scheme to the doors of the Assembly on Monday.

Jon McCourt, of Survivors North West, called on Stormont chiefs to listen closely and take their advice seriously: “Victims and survivors are a very vulnerable group – some of them are very elderly and have health problems. The Executive office should move with urgency to consult with victims and to then set up the redress scheme.

“We have waited for justice for long enough.”

Survivors, backed by Amnesty International, called for the Assembly to “secure and ring fence” money for compensation funds.

The £20m to £30m costs were calculated by Quarter Chartered Accountants. The company was commissioned by the independent Panel of Experts on Redress, which includes Ms McGuckin and Mr McCourt, survivors, their representative groups, academics, lawyers, human rights organisations and others.

It proposed a basic £10,000 payment for anyone who suffered child abuse in an institution, with length of time spent in a home also taken into account, along with assessment of mental, physical and sexual abuse suffered.

Survivors said a Government-run compensation scheme would be more cost-effective and much less traumatic for victims than the courts.

The campaigners urged Stormont ministers to open talks on a potential scheme and on the financial contribution to be made by religious orders and other organisations which ran many of the children’s homes where abuse took place.