The inside story of the search for Nicola Bulley, as told by her family, the police and social media sleuths
Thursday: The Search for Nicola Bulley (BBC1, 9pm)
On Friday, January 27, 2023, 45-year-old Nicola Bulley went missing while walking her dog along her usual morning route beside the River Wyre in the Lancashire village of St Michael’s on Wyre.
The subsequent search sparked an extraordinary international media frenzy. There seemed to be no reason the mortgage adviser would want to disappear, and her dog was found running loose and her phone was still on a teams call, which added to the sense mystery surrounding the case.
It wasn’t just the papers and TV news that took an interest in the case. Something about the mother-of-two’s story also captured the attention of social media. While the police suspected Nicola had fallen into the river, many internet sleuths believed she may have been abducted and were quick to share their theories online. Some went a step further and turned up to St Michael’s on Wyre to conduct their own amateur ‘investigations’.
The case would ultimately have a tragic ending. On February 19, Nicola’s body was discovered in the river just over a mile from where she had last been seen. The coroner ruled that she had died accidentally from drowning.
Now, this documentary, which includes interviews with Nicola’s family and the people closest to the case, including journalists and Lancashire police, will explore how the investigation unfolded, and ask why the story struck such a chord with the public.
It will also look at some of the wider questions the handling of the investigation raised. During the search, Lancashire Police was criticised for releasing sensitive information about Nicola, which an independent review later described as “avoidable and unnecessary”.
Then there were the amateur detectives. It was reported that Lancashire Constabulary press office logged more than 75,000 inbound social media comments on the case over a period of around a month. This documentary explores how the impact of the theories on the investigation and on Nicola’s family.
Perhaps during the search, some people posting online lost sight of the fact that they were speculating about real people going through a traumatic time and ultimately suffering a tragic loss. However, this programme puts Nicola and her loved ones back at the heart of the story.
In a statement, the family said: “Collectively we thought long and hard about taking part in a documentary about Nikki. It wasn’t an easy decision. Nikki’s face and name quickly became very recognisable, but there is so much to share about Nikki the person.
“Our sole aim is to provide the definitive record on Nikki to ensure she has the legacy that she deserves. Many people have aired their views about her disappearance and her untimely and tragic death, only we can speak about her as a mummy, partner, daughter, and sister.”
They added: “In addition, if our experience of being in the eye of a media storm makes people think twice about how they act and what they say online, then we will have achieved some further good.”