Business concerns over Good Jobs Bill remain unresolved

​Business leaders express disappointment that political divisions have prevented progress on a balanced approach to employment rights legislation

As we approach the end of this session of the Assembly, it is unfortunate that ‘employment rights’ have proved to be such a divisive issue, leading to acrimony and political paralysis when there was significant common ground at the outset.

Alan Lowry, FSB`s NI chairplaceholder image
Alan Lowry, FSB`s NI chair

The so-called “Good Jobs Bill” could have provided an opportunity to bring many aspects of our employment legislation up to date, particularly following two separate periods of Stormont’s collapse. However, an ideological fixation on bringing trade unions into the smallest of workplaces generated real concerns among business owners and ultimately saw faultlines emerge within the Assembly.

For several decades, business owners have worked to remove division from our workplaces, building positive relationships and ensuring harmonious relations between employer and employee. The result has been balance, employment growth and shared prosperity – good jobs, by anyone’s reckoning. That progress has been built on trust, communication and a shared understanding of the needs of both businesses and their employees.

A vast number of the proposals contained within the Bill are already being taken forward by employers who recognise that, in a buoyant labour market, employees have choices and businesses need to remain attractive places to work if they are to recruit and retain talented people. Good employers understand that investing in their workforce is essential to the long-term success of their business.

The prospect of legislating to introduce a third party into such workplaces, with the clear and stated intent of creating ‘sides’, with trade unions taking one position against the other in what were previously balanced workplaces, is anathema to the entrepreneurs who have started their own businesses and worked hard to build positive working environments.

Some of our political parties chose to engage with business owners and listen to their concerns. That is not only welcome but essential. Any legislation that can so dramatically affect the employers on whom the majority of our labour force rely must be shaped by those who understand the practical realities of running a business and the environment in which they have to operate.

Proposals to separate the updating of employment rights from the ideological drive to strengthen the trade unions could have secured widespread support. There was an opportunity to make meaningful progress on employment legislation while addressing the concerns of employers, but unfortunately those proposals were cast aside. That is regrettable.

In England, where new trade union access powers came into force within the last month, it took just three minutes before thousands of requests for access started to inundate employers and business owners across the country.

To expose small businesses to that sort of pressure, and all the distraction that it could create, is an unacceptable diversion from the real challenges of succeeding in business. Those challenges include managing costs, responding to changing market conditions, investing for growth and, ultimately, continuing to provide good jobs for good employees.

It is regrettable that the whole process has been so unedifying; that the voices of businesses have not been sufficiently accommodated to allow consensus to be reached; that it has been permitted to become such a divisive issue; and that some organisations have had to spend so much political capital standing against damaging proposals.

Those organisations have, in turn, been pilloried for doing so when, in reality, they were simply reflecting the deep concerns expressed by business owners. Their role has been to represent those concerns and ensure that the practical consequences of proposed legislation are properly understood.

There was an opportunity to deliver an updated and balanced framework for employment rights, with the support of both employers and employees. It is disappointing that the debate has become so polarised and that, as this Assembly session draws to a close, that opportunity has not been fully realised.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice