Demolition of Victorian building back on cards? Developer appeals blocked South Belfast apartments plan

The demolition of a Victorian building could be back on the cards, despite Belfast Council bowing to people power by blocking it.

Over the summer, the council denied a property developer planning permission to knock down a house that’s stood on Annadale Avenue, in the south of the city, for over 120 years.

A CGI impression of the proposed apartments. Image: Cregagh Developmentsplaceholder image
A CGI impression of the proposed apartments. Image: Cregagh Developments

Cregagh Developments Ltd wanted to build flats on the site, though the idea garnered more than 20 objections, including one from Belfast South and Mid Down MP Claire Hanna and one from the organisation Ulster Architectural Heritage.

Objectors said the demolition of the existing building would negatively impact on the Victorian character of the area, as well as voicing concerns it would set a precedent, and stating that knocking down the house would be a great historical and cultural loss.

Belfast City Hall councillors voted to break with their own officials by refusing planning permission.placeholder image
Belfast City Hall councillors voted to break with their own officials by refusing planning permission.

The Department for Infrastructure’s Rivers section and Northern Ireland Water also raised issues – but council planning officers had recommended granting planning permission anyway, albeit with a list of conditions.

Politicians voted to break with their own officials, deciding to put a stop to the plans.

But now the developers have challenged that refusal, going to a higher provincewide planning authority in the hope of having the block rescinded to allow the scheme to start.

Information released by the Planning Appeals Commission state the developer lodged details with them last month. It’ll likely be next year at the earliest before the case is heard.

But the move could mean demolition is back on the cards.

At a meeting of the council’s Planning Committee in August, 12 politicians voted to block the plans. A further six, all from the DUP, were in favour of granting permission to the developers.

A representative of nearby residents told that meeting: “We are quite concerned about the imposing nature of this build, and how close it is to our border. The southwest facade is quite overbearing, and we are even worried about our mature shrubs.

“It would be so sad to see this beautiful old building demolished. The incredible Victorian gardens at the back, with sweet pea and apple trees, would be turned into a parking lot.”

However an agent for the developers said the site had been investigated, and it was “not viable” to keep the building intact.

Stated the agent: “The applicants committed to the sustainability principle to salvage materials such as red brick, roof tiles and stone sills for reuse in the proposed development.

“But importantly, the existing building is not listed, and is not located in a conservation area.”

Alliance Party councillor Tara Brooks felt it would be “a crime” to demolish the building, telling August’s committee she “cannot in all conscience vote to permit its demolition”.

However DUP alderman Dean McCullough argued that whatever ideas people have for the site, “viability is viability”.

“I don’t know what else [the developer] can do,” he said. “They have come to this committee time and time again, with amendment after amendment.”

In their official notice of planning refusal, council planners state the existing building “makes an important material contribution” to that part of Belfast, and its demolition to be replaced with a more modern apartment block would “erode the important Victorian character and appearance of the area”.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice