John O'Dowd under fire over 'cack-handed rates fiasco' as he halts planned hike amid outcry from pubs and restaurants
Political rivals have strongly criticised Sinn Fein's finance minister John O'Dowd over a planned rates hike for businesses - something which he has now decided to halt.
Mr O'Dowd announced today that he was putting a stop to the planned rise in business rates, which had been due to kick in from April, adding that he is in “listening mode” on the issue.
Some firms, particularly hospitality ones, had complained that the rises they were facing were extremely steep.
After the u-turn today, the UUP described the minister's handling of the situation as indicative of "Sinn Fein's tone-deaf approach to the economy", while the SDLP dubbed it a "fiasco", Alliance called it "cack-handed", and the TUV said it revealed "how detached Stormont has become from the real economy".


The DUP meanwhile said that “while pausing the process is welcome, it also raises serious questions about the minister’s judgement in allowing things to progress to this stage”.
WHAT HAS HAPPENED?:
Land and Property Services (LPS, part of Stormont's Department of Finance) periodically reviews the rateable value of commercial premises.
This is generally based on "the annual rental value that your property could reasonably be expected to be let for if it was on the open market".
But for pubs and hotels, it is different.
Instead, their calculation is based on “fair maintainable trade” – which is largely an estimate of turnover, as opposed to just rental value.
Northern Ireland's previous reassessment of rental values had been based on a snapshot of the situation in October 2021.
The latest valuation – which was published last week by LPS – is based on figures from April 2024.
What has happened is that because the last valuation was based on trading figures in the midst of Covid, as the pandemic subsided, turnover rose for pubs and hotels, according to a spokesman for Hospitality Ulster, the industry trade body.
This has led to pubs’ and hotels' rateable values in particular now shooting up (the spokesman also said that rampant inflation between 2021 and 2024 was a big contributor to the rise, too).
Now, after an outcry from pubs and hotels, minister O'Dowd said today that the planned rates hike has been "stopped".
In a statement this afternoon, he said: "I want our local businesses to thrive; they are the backbone of our communities.
“I have listened carefully and I am very aware of the concerns raised by businesses - particularly hotels, pubs and other hospitality businesses.
“I remain in listening mode, I will now consider the next steps.
"My focus remains on supporting our public services, our local businesses and growing our economy."
‘NOTHING IS OFF THE TABLE’:
Earlier, a spokesman for The Galgorm luxury resort outside Ballymena had told the Nolan Show that it currently has an annual rates bill of £585,000 - but that, come April, this was set to jump to £1.4m.
"So the increase is larger than the current bill," he said.
"When you break that down, it's around £66,000 a month extra we'll need to find, with eight weeks' notice."
Colin Neill, chief executive of Hospitality Ulster, had told the show "I've never seen the industry so upset, so annoyed, so worried".
He said that "we expect a rise in rates", but that some firms had been left looking at hikes up to 300%.
He gave an example of Horatio Todd's pub in east Belfast, saying that its annual rates bill was set to rise from about £104,000 to £182,000 under the plans.
Mr Neill had raised the prospect of "protests", saying that a "working group" had been set up to look into what this could involve.
Mr Neill noted that, in England, Labour MPs had been barred from some pubs over the rates increase there.
Could a similar thing happen here, he was asked.
"Nothing is off the table," he had replied.
‘JUDGEMENT IN QUESTION’:
There has been a wide welcome for the minister’s decision to halt the changes.
David Higgins, chairman of Retail NI said it had come “at a time when retailers are trying to adjust to recent increase in employers’ National Insurance and the increase in minimum wage”.
He added there must now be “real reflection” about any planned changes.
Meanwhile the Belfast Chamber (one-third of whose members are in hospitality) said it had been “encouraging to see common sense prevail” on the issue.
UUP economy spokeswoman Diana Armstrong MLA said the “climbdown… starkly highlights Sinn Fein's tone-deaf approach to the economy”.
She added: “Is this a case of Sinn Fein policy taking precedence above all else, and could such policies be acting as a deliberate wrecking ball to Northern Ireland's economy?”
DUP finance spokeswoman Diane Forsythe called for “clarity on next steps,” adding: “While pausing the process is welcome, it also raises serious questions about the minister’s judgement in allowing things to progress to this stage.”
And TUV leader Jim Allister MP said: “I welcome the fact that the finance Minister has now halted the proposed revaluation of business rates, but this climbdown only underlines how detached Stormont has become from the real economy.
“This damaging proposal should never have reached the stage it did… it took a public backlash to force the minister into ‘listening mode’.”
And Mr Neill of Hospitality Ulster said the process had “brought hospitality to this crisis point”.
The rates hike “would have been the death knell for our industry” he said, adding that “we now look forward to working with the minister to come to a solution that allows the sector to pay its fair share”.