Spending £5m of public money on MOT deal that collapsed 'an absolute disgrace'
The Department of Infrastructure’s handling of an ill-fated deal with a Californian company has been described as an “absolute disgrace”.
The UUP’s infrastructure spokesman John Stewart MLA made the comments after an Audit Office report into the deal to supply MOT equipment was published today.


It found that the agreement for new testing equipment and IT systems, signed for £10.8m, ended up costing the public purse £5.1m without actually delivering what it was supposed to.
The deal with US firm Worldwide Environmental Products, Inc (WEP) was unveiled in March 2019, at a time when there was no minister in place due to Sinn Fein’s three-year boycott of Stormont.
WEP’s bid had come in 53% lower than the only other compliant bid, and was 40% below what the DVA had expected to pay.
In 2022, when it became clear that the deal was not working, the DVA began moves to end the contract.
Eventually it agreed to pay WEP £1.5m to walk away – added to which the DVA had incurred £3.6m in its own costs.
The contract was ended without admission of fault.
Mr Stewart said: “More than £5 million of taxpayers’ money is gone, motorists have faced years of delay, and there is nothing to show for it.
“At a time when people right across Northern Ireland are struggling to get an MOT appointment, this is a staggering failure of public administration.
"Taxpayers are entitled to know how a bid 40% below the Department’s own estimate was accepted without proper assurance that it could actually be delivered.”
He said the report raises “serious questions” which “need to be answered in full”.
“The original contract was signed before Liz Kimmins became infrastructure minister, but this is her service now, and it is up to her to put it right.
“I want the minister to come before the Assembly and explain how this happened, who has been held to account, and what will stop it happening again.”
The department told the News Letter: “The department welcomes the publication of the NI Audit Office report and is considering the findings.
"No further comment will be made until the Assembly process is complete.”