Failings exposed by Noah Donohoe case could lead to further deaths, court warned

Failings exposed by the inquest for schoolboy Noah Donohoe could lead to further deaths if they are not addressed, a coroner has been told.

The Belfast teenager was found dead in an underground water tunnel in the north of the city in June 2020. He had drowned.

Noah Donohoeplaceholder image
Noah Donohoe

Last month a jury in the long-running inquest found that failings by Stormont’s Department for Infrastructure around its management of access to the water culvert possibly contributed to the 14-year-old’s death.

The jury found there were no police failings that contributed to Noah’s death – after unanimously agreeing that he died on the same day he disappeared.

However, jurors identified a series of subsequent investigative errors by officers that impacted the ability of the jury to reach conclusions on aspects of the long-running case.

While the jury has delivered its findings, the inquest has yet to formally conclude.

One outstanding matter still to be determined is whether coroner Mr Justice Rooney will exercise his powers to make a report to the DfI and PSNI if he believes actions should be taken to prevent similar fatalities in the future.

At a hearing in Belfast Coroners’ Court on Tuesday, a barrister for Noah’s mother Fiona said the inquest had exposed “really concerning” failings that “if not put right, we would submit might well lead to future deaths”.

Brenda Campbell KC said it would be important for the coroner to know what “up-to-date” steps the department and police had taken since Noah’s death to address the issues highlighted by the inquest.

A fuller hearing has been scheduled for November 5 when legal parties in the case will make submissions to the coroner on whether they consider it appropriate for him to issue a report based on the inquest findings.

Barristers for the DfI and PSNI told the coroner on Tuesday they will make submissions on the matter.

Noah, a pupil at St Malachy’s College, went missing after leaving home in south Belfast on his bike to meet two friends in the Cavehill area of the city.

He took a detour on his journey and shortly before entering the area where the culvert was located, he was captured on CCTV cycling naked.

The case had long been surrounded by mystery and Noah’s mother has campaigned for answers.

The jury found there was insufficient evidence to explain Noah’s behaviour after he left his house at 5.40pm on June 21. Jurors determined that he died in the water tunnel between 7pm and midnight that night.

His mother had reported him missing to police at around 9.45pm that night.

While the jury found it was not “probable” that failings by the DfI contributed to Noah’s death, they did agree that it was “possible”.

Jurors said a failure to identify the culvert entrance as a location that the public could possibly access meant no warning signs were erected at the location and it was only covered by a debris screen.

Given jurors found that Noah died on the day he went missing, the jury found that police errors or inaction did not contribute to his death.

However, jurors identified 13 subsequent failings that impacted upon the ability of the inquest to reach a conclusion on aspect/aspects relevant to the circumstances of the death.

Most of the errors related to the police investigation.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice