Plan to partially demolish listed building and build new hotel in Belfast 'wrongly focused on profit' court told
Plans to partially demolish a listed building and build a new hotel in Belfast city centre are wrongly focused on maximising profit, the High Court heard today.
Lawyers for a campaign group also claimed the City Council failed to properly explore any viable alternative ways of retaining the structure of an old RUC station on Queen Street.


The Ulster Architectural Heritage Society (UAHS) is challenging the authority’s decision to approve the project.
Barrister Ronan Lavery KC argued demolition should only take place as a last resort. “Buildings are just torn down by developers because it is more economically viable,” he submitted.
Legal action was taken after the Council gave the go-ahead to build a 74 bedroom luxury hotel at 21 Queen Street.
Dating back to the nineteenth century, the Grade B1 listed building was originally constructed as a children’s hospital before being transformed into an RUC barracks. It is believed to have been vacant since 2000 and now features on a ‘buildings at risk’ register.
The development proposals involve retaining and restoring the front section on Queen Street, but demolishing two separate linked structures towards the rear onto College Court.
Approval for the scheme was previously quashed by the High Court amid objections based on the architectural heritage.
But in December 2024 the Council again granted planning permission to pull down the rear structures and erect a nine-storey hotel with an associated bar, restaurant and ancillary facilities.
According to the UAHS, that decision was unlawful, unreasonable and irrational.
The campaign group claimed it breached planning policies by failing to provide valid reasons and properly exploring any alternative options.
It also sought an order prohibiting the developer from carrying out any demolition work pending a final determination of the application for a judicial review.
The group is also seeking an order prohibiting developer Big Top Productions from carrying out any demolition work pending a final determination in the challenge.
The Council’s lawyers have stressed how the main section will be saved under the proposals.
Concerns were also identified about the deteriorating state of parts of the structure, with predictions that the main part of the listed building could be lost unless steps are taken quickly.
According to the heritage society, however, the exceptional circumstances required for demolition do not exist.
Mr Lavery also suggested a smaller, boutique hotel could have been a potential alternative option.
“It is speculative development by a commercial enterprise that wants to maximise the economic viability of the site,” he insisted.
“This is a real place people would have had access to, a building that reflects our history, rather than some virtual reality museum.”
The case continues.