'Uncomfortable reading' for Andrew Muir as DAERA found to be in breach of wild bird laws

The Northern Irish government has been found to have broken conservation laws, with minister Andrew Muir saying the findings make “uncomfortable reading”.

The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has issued a report today castigating Stormont’s Department of Agriculture, the Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) for falling short of what the law requires when it comes to protecting wild birds.

Puffins on Rathlin Island (RSPB). The island is a Special Protection Area, designed to protect birds like puffins and corncrakes. A new report has criticised DAERA for not expanding the number of such zonesplaceholder image
Puffins on Rathlin Island (RSPB). The island is a Special Protection Area, designed to protect birds like puffins and corncrakes. A new report has criticised DAERA for not expanding the number of such zones

The OEP is a small public body covering England and Northern Ireland, set up in 2021 to “provide independent oversight of the government’s environmental progress”.

The OEP has now issued “decision notices” to DAERA setting out its failings, to which DAERA is legally obliged to respond.

If the OEP finds the problems are not being remedied, it can take DAERA to court.

DAERA has pointed to a “failure of successive administrations” to act on the issue.

The bits of law that the OEP says DAERA has broken are the Conservation (Natural Habitats, etc.) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1995 and the EU directive 2009/147/EC.

Helen Venn, OEP chief regulatory officer, said in particular that DAERA has failed to designate new Special Protection Areas for wild birds.

There are currently 16 such zones in Northern Ireland, ranging from Pettigoe Plateau in Co Fermanagh to Lough Foyle, Rathlin Island, and Carlingford Lough.

Ms Venn said: “The wild bird populations in Northern Ireland continue to show a significant decline.

"This paints a very concerning picture for wild birds but also for the wider environment as birds are an indicator of how nature is doing.”

As such, it is “important for DAERA to carry out its legal responsibilities in a reasonable timeframe to deliver nature recovery”.

Minister Muir said: “We have a moral and legal obligation to protect and enhance the habitats, species and ecosystems that we share this planet with, and I believe there are huge societal benefits of returning to a world rich in nature.

“The findings of this OEP investigation make for uncomfortable reading.

"The OEP has recognised in their investigation longstanding and concerning failures to implement recommended actions to protect wild bird habitats and populations by successive administrations both in England and Northern Ireland."

In response, Joanne Sherwood, Northern Ireland director of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) said the findings were “no surprise”, and “confirm what conservation organisations have been saying… we hope today’s OEP report will be the catalyst needed” for change.

So how bad is the situation for birdlife in the Province?

In its press release today, the OEP referred to the birds data found in the 2023 State of Nature report.

This was compiled by a collective of bodies including the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), and the Ulster Wildlife Trust, and its authors describe it as “the most comprehensive report on the UK’s current biodiversity”.

It found “a decrease in abundance on average of 43% between 1996 and 2021” of 17 farmland bird species in Northern Ireland, while 21 woodland bird species had declined by 18% – though it found that 26 other breeding birds had increased in abundance by 30%.

Overall, across all of the 64 breeding species above which the report monitored, abundance had declined by 10%.

Meanwhile the report also looked at 36 wintering waterbird species, and stated that these declined by 30% between 1988 and 2019.

The OEP had previously found DAERA failed to comply with environmental law over its ammonia advice in 2024.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice