MLA warns A5 landowners can't be short changed as minister confirms compensation will be at 2024 values
Landowners along the route of the A5 upgrade face being “short changed” after the infrastructure minister told the Assembly that they will be compensated for vested land as 2024 values, an Ulster Unionist MLA has said.
Diana Armstrong raised the issue in the Assembly as the minister responded to questions after the Court of Appeal ruling allowing the A5 project to go ahead.


She asked whether farmers whose land was vested in November 2024 would be compensated at 2024 values or at today's market values.
The Minister replied that under the current legislation the valuation remains at November 2024 levals – and that it was not within her remit to change. However, she said every case would be looked at on merit, and her officials would be “engaging with those landowners in the time ahead”.
Speaking afterwards, Fermanagh and South Tyrone MLA Mrs Armstrong said: “That answer will land badly with every farming family along that route, and it should. These farmers had their land taken in November 2024. It was handed back in June 2025 when the vesting orders were quashed. Now it is to be taken again, in late 2026, and they are to be paid prices from two years ago.
“Every other cost in this project moves with the market. Contractors, materials, labour, professional fees, all at today's rates. The only thing frozen in time is the land taken from farmers. A farmer paid at 2024 values cannot go out and buy replacement land in today's market, because that land is not available at that price any more. The shortfall does not disappear. It simply falls on the farm family instead of on the project.
“The Minister told me this is not within her remit to change. I would say this to her. Saying the law produces an unfair outcome is not a defence of that outcome. It is an argument for changing the law. Legislation has been brought to this Assembly for a great deal less.
“The Minister also said every case will be looked at on its merits, and I want to know what that means in practice. If the valuation date is fixed in statute, what discretion actually exists?
“Farmers deserve a straight answer rather than a reassuring phrase.”