Esmond Birnie: 10 years on, Brexit has not been the economic disaster it was predicted to be for both UK and Northern Ireland

We are approaching the 10th anniversary of the Brexit referendum on June 23. Much ink will be spilt regarding the impact of that vote.

Since 2016, UK economic growth has been the same as France and double the rate of Germanyplaceholder image
Since 2016, UK economic growth has been the same as France and double the rate of Germany

Some politicians and commentators have been getting their retaliation in first. A lot of the commentary is pretty lurid.

Although it may have been a tactical position to become the next Labour leader, and hence prime minister, former Cabinet minister Wes Streeting has declared Brexit a “catastrophic mistake”.

On the political Right, former Conservative leader William Hague provided a more measured but still arguable summary: “Leaving the EU has been very costly for the British people” (The Times, 19 May 2026).

Dr Esmond Birnie is senior economist at Ulster University Business Schoolplaceholder image
Dr Esmond Birnie is senior economist at Ulster University Business School

Ten years ago we were bombarded with a range of economic forecasts coming from a host of UK and international economic experts and think tanks. Almost every one of these studies, whether from the UK Treasury, or the major consulting firms, or universities or bodies such as the IMF, predicted that if the UK voted to leave the consequence after about 10-15 years would be that national output would be much reduced compared to the level it would otherwise have been.

Some of those studies even predicted that the immediate result of a Brexit vote would be a severe economic recession. The experts were clearly wrong about that. The UK economy continued to grow until Covid intervened in 2020.

As to the longer run prediction of economic harm over the following 10-15 years, this remains economic gospel. The independent Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR)’s working assumption is that Brexit implies UK GDP (output) is about 4% less than what it would have been. That OBR figure is regularly quoted by government and politicians.

What almost nobody notes is that the OBR produced no research of their own to substantiate that estimate. What they did was simply take the average of the dozen or so studies which had been conducted back in 2016. This is a very crude method (for a more detailed assessment see Graham Gudgin, 4 April 2026, “Rachel Reeves Wrong on Brexit”, Briefings for Britain, https://www.briefingsforbritain.co.uk/rachel-reeves-wrong-brexit-damage/)

The claim that Brexit has imposed a very considerable cost on to the UK or Northern Ireland economies relies on the assumption that in the absence of Brexit we would have maintained a reasonably high rate of economic growth.

What the Remainers/Brexit reversers do not tell us is that since 2016 UK (and Northern Ireland) economic growth has been far from catastrophic, even though it hasn’t been brilliant either. In fact, it has been about the same as that of France and double the rate of Germany (the EU’s second and first largest economies).

During 2016-25, Northern Ireland’s total output grew by about 12.6%, slightly faster than the UK total at about 11.7%. French GDP grew by about 11.6% and Germany’s by 5.4%.

Admittedly, the USA did much better than either the UK or EU, displaying a growth of about 24.3% – but this was probably caused by unique factors such as the AI boom in America and the impact of large budget deficits.

So, the economic data does not display the marked cost from Brexit which we have been told so much about.

In the case of Northern Ireland it is worth repeating that growth has been better than that of the main EU economies such as France and Germany, so that suggests Brexit has been far from catastrophic.

In fact, some of Northern Ireland’s main economic problems, such as the relatively low level of GDP per person and associated low levels of labour productivity (output per worker), long pre-date Brexit in 2016.

Northern Ireland’s level of GDP per person was about 80% of the UK level in 2016 (just it had been back in the 1920s) and it was still about 80% in the most recent data. Brexit has hardly moved the dial in either direction.

What we do see in the case of Northern Ireland is some evidence which is indicative of trade diversion. Given the extra costs to businesses consequent from the Irish Sea Border as a result of the Protocol/Windsor Framework arrangements during 2019-24, Northern Ireland’s import of goods from GB increased by 16.2%, whereas the flow from the Republic of Ireland grew by 27.5%.

And there is very little evidence that Northern Ireland is really reaping a benefit from so-called Dual Market Access: the extent of access which we have to both the UK Internal Market and the EU’s Single Market.

In 2024-25, Northern Ireland’s rate of inward investment (employment per head of the population) was only half the UK average. There is some evidence (the EY surveys) that the number of investment projects coming to Belfast have declined relative to the numbers going to the larger cities in the north of GB.

What of the current push to reverse Brexit, putting to one side the important point the EU will not let us back on the pre-2016 terms?

Even more so than in the rest of the UK, Northern Ireland requires politicians to make hard choices about things like the planning system, energy costs, training, immigration, defence and welfare spending.

Rejoining the EU would represent the greatest of distractions from such priorities.

l Dr Esmond Birnie, senior economist, Ulster University Business School

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice