Esmond Birnie: Unintended consequence of Trump’s silly Greenland tariffs could be a worsening of the Irish Sea border
At least two (Northern Ireland-related) economic points can be made about Trump’s Greenland-related tariff gambit.


• Impact on NI economy if US tariffs on UK origin goods go from 10% in general now to (eventually) 35%
This is indeed bad new. Assuming NI businesses selling into the US cannot afford to take the hit in terms of slimming their profits they would have to raise prices in the US by up to 35%. Given a reasonable (and possibly even modest assumption) about the “price elasticity of demand” for NI exports into the US (based on Bank of England figures) 35% higher prices would lead to demand for those goods in the US dropping by about 17.5% (i.e. each 1% increase in price leads to sales dropping by 0.5%).
Using official figures NI’s annual sales of goods into the US have been about £1.5bn. So a 17.5% decline would be equivalent to just over £200m and hence a loss of output to the NI economy of that order of magnitude equivalent to about 0.3% of NI’s GDP. And that figure does not allow for further negative consequences, notably from any retaliatory tariffs on the part of the UK/EU (see below) or, indeed, the impact of a generally slower growth rate of world trade given the way in which the President’s trade policy has created massive and continuous uncertainty.
• What about retaliation by the UK and/or EU?
As of early on Monday the mood music coming from 10 Downing Street is that the UK will not retaliate in the form of raising tariffs against US imports. If this continues to be PM Starmer’s stance he could claim he is line with classic economic theory in defence of free trade – even if a foreign country imposes tariffs on your country’s exports why would you impose an added pain on domestic consumers by raising prices at home through retaliatory tariffs? Just because America is shooting itself in the foot there is no need for the UK to follow that bad practice! That said, given the peculiarities of the psychology of how the American president makes policy it may be that retaliation could at least provide a valuable bargaining tool which might cause him to back down in the longer run. Trump did, for example, crumble in the face of Chinese counter tariffs.
If the EU does impose retaliatory tariffs (probably through the anti-coercion instrument popularly known as the bazooka) which must be reasonably likely (up to now the EU has not retaliated at the US tariffs which previously settled at 15% on EU goods going to the US) that will very probably have an impact on NI. Under the Protocol/Windsor Framework NI is de facto part of the single market and subject to its rules.
That implies if the EU puts a tariff on a US good coming into the single market that would have to also apply on that US good coming into Belfast. NI based importers would face the pain of having to pay up to, say, 40% (ie equivalent to the US 15% plus 25% tariff in the other direction) tariffs on US goods coming into NI. Admittedly, the Windsor Framework provision would allow for NI businesses paying such tariffs, provided the goods were not for further transit on into the single market, to reclaim the tariff. Unfortunately, previous experience is that such rebate arrangements are cumbersome and take time to complete. There would thus be an up-front charge on NI businesses and a potentially damaging impact on their cash flow.
The bottom line is that it is quite possible that an unintended consequence of this trade war about Greenland is going to be a sizeable increase in the so-called ‘Irish Sea border’.
All this is bad but sadly the bad economics of the silly Greenland-related tariff are only the tip of the iceberg. The truly disastrous aspect of Trump’s aspiration to take-over Greenland by whatever means is that is very hard to see how the collective security aspect of the Nato alliance can survive this. Denmark, the legal owner of Greenland, is, after all, part of that alliance along with the other countries which the US president is now threatening with trade war (or worse). This is why former US National Security advisor John Bolton has termed Trump’s latest policy his “most dangerous and destructive” to date.
Whatever the merits or otherwise of the UK’s 100 year lease deal relating to the Diego Garcia military base, Trump should not be dismissing the UK in tones of heavy sarcasm as “our ‘brilliant’ NATO Ally”.
Given recent behaviour by China and Russia we have to hope that wise heads at the tops of America’s Republic and Democratic parties will be calculating how such policies are eroding the geopolitical security of the entire democratic world including the US.
We also await, possibly, later this week a judgement from the US Supreme Court as to whether presidential policy on tariffs has been constitutional.
• Dr Esmond Birnie, Senior Economist Ulster University Business School