Jackie McGregor: Worried everyone in the room is judging you? Blame your inner caveman
“I wish I’d gone on a diet… I knew I should’ve bought that other top,” my twenty-something pal fretted as she rushed to get ready. She was meeting her new partner’s friends for the first time.
“I can hardly breathe, I think I’m hyperventilating,” she gasped, as her anxiety began to spiral.


“What if they don’t like me?” she wailed.
“That’s the least of your worries. Have you seen the size of your backside in those trousers?” I asked.
“Oh God, is it huge?” she cried, instantly spinning to the mirror and surveying it from all angles.
“No, but you’ve stopped panting” I pointed out.
“That was mean,” she complained.
I smiled. “It took your mind off hyperventilating.”
She exhaled, relaxing a little.
Watching her whip herself into a frenzy took me back to my younger self, and the night my father sat me down and gave me some sage advice. I, too, had been worried about my appearance and the sort of impression I’d make when I went to a social gathering.
I was in a tizzy about my outfit and was on the point of cancelling altogether. I feared upon arrival, I would be silently judged by an imaginary panel of Craig Revel Horwoods, all holding up score paddles.
Dad offered his words of wisdom, which, at the time, I was utterly appalled by.
His advice? Nobody cares.
Back then in my melodramatic youth, my fragile ego couldn’t make sense of this. As far as I was concerned, my very existence would be critiqued by all.
Everyone would surely notice the horrible cowlick my fringe had suddenly developed, and the spot the size of a small continent erupting on my nose. I thought dad was out of touch - that it was different for men, and my outfit, was in fact, a matter of national importance.
Now, decades later, I realise he was right. Psychologists actually have a name for it; the spotlight effect. It describes how we wander around thinking everyone has us under surveillance, noticing our every flaw, when people are usually completely self-absorbed.
In a crowded room a woman could be staring at your shoes. You begin to catastrophise that she’s judging you, appalled by your footwear choices. In reality, she’s in her own head, worrying if she locked the front door, as her obsessive-compulsive impulses kick in. Someone else might be glaring your way.
You assume he’s being unfriendly, but he’s just staring right through you, panicking about his next mortgage payment.
We regularly torture ourselves, obsessing over imaginary judgements. It makes you wonder why? Scientifically speaking, it isn’t a lack of confidence, it’s a design defect.
Our caveman selves are still running data in the background of our brains. We are beings for whom social rejection once represented mortal peril. We evolved in small tribes where drawing the wrong kind of attention meant getting ostracised from the group, leading to almost certain death if we had to survive alone. Our brains haven’t forgotten that, even if the world has changed.
But people rarely notice us anymore. They’re busy scrolling zombie-like, searching for the meaning of life on social media.
I smiled later, thinking about my friend worrying whether people will like her or not. Most people don’t even like themselves.