Owen Polley: ​Starmer and Labour’s failings fuel fire of a nationalist resurgence

​​Sir Keir Starmer has a lot to answer for. Last week’s elections on the mainland showed the extent to which he has let down his party and the entire country.

The public has quickly become disillusioned with Sir Keir Starmer. Photo: Maja Smiejkowska/PA Wireplaceholder image
The public has quickly become disillusioned with Sir Keir Starmer. Photo: Maja Smiejkowska/PA Wire

Starmer’s arrival at Number 10 was supposed to mean a quieter, more predictable spell of government, after the rancour of Brexit and the disruptions of Covid. It was supposed to allow the UK to heal a little after a period of division.

In Northern Ireland, even unionist leaders hoped that Labour would bring better relationships with the EU and a less intrusive Irish Sea border.

In Wales, the devolved Labour government had become almost like an insurgent nationalist party, when the Conservatives were in power at Westminster. It was hardly fanciful to assume that it would work more harmoniously with a Labour prime minister.

In Scotland, the SNP was in trouble at the last general election.

The party was finally being punished for almost two decades of incompetence at Holyrood and its implication in repeated scandals.

Labour was back on top and there were realistic hopes that it might soon form Scotland’s government, for the first time since 2006.

Some unionists suggested that Labour was a more reliable custodian of the Union than the Conservative and Unionist party.

You aren’t likely to hear that claim this week.

Instead of an era of stability, Starmer’s premiership has resulted in the resurgence of nationalist parties in Scotland and Wales, as well as the continued rise of Reform and the Greens across the whole of Great Britain.

The separatist parties will likely intensify their demands to break up the UK, citing comparative success at these elections. The media has already focused on the fact that the devolved administrations will all (nominally) be led by nationalists.

This is certainly an unfortunate piece of symbolism, but it is misleading.

Northern Ireland has a Sinn Fein first minister, but Michelle O’Neill’s powers are identical to her ‘co-equal’ deputy, Emma Little-Pengelly. That is the whole point of our power-sharing system.

In Scotland and Wales, Labour’s unpopularity effectively left a vacuum that was filled by nationalists.

The Welsh nationalist party, Plaid Cymru, became the biggest party at the Senedd, by a narrow margin. But Reform’s success in Wales, coming from nowhere to claim second place, showed that voters are desperately looking for other options.

Polling suggests that less than a quarter of people there support independence and even Plaid is coy about whether it intends to pursue a complete rupture with the rest of the UK.

The campaign against the Union is admittedly more serious in Scotland.

The SNP will claim that its supporters voted to leave the UK and that it has a fresh mandate for an independence referendum, even though its vote share and number of seats dropped.

The fact is, though, that it was governing before the election.

Its record was not impressive: falling standards in Scottish schools, the highest drug deaths in Europe, steeper income tax than the rest of the UK and Scotland becoming arguably the ‘wokest region’ of Britain. But successive SNP administrations were effective at blaming all their problems on Westminster, while using the Treasury’s money to pay for extras that were not available in England.

The arrival of a Labour prime minister was expected to make this tactic less successful, but nobody anticipated the public becoming so disillusioned so quickly with Keir Starmer.

The government should ensure that new demands for a referendum are countered robustly, particularly because the SNP failed to get a majority at Holyrood. There was a poll on this issue only in 2014, and everybody understood the result would stand for at least a generation.

The new, unpredictable elements in politics across the UK are the Greens and particular Reform, which was the big winner nationally.

Despite their strong performances, it still seems likely this was because of frustration with Labour and the Conservatives, rather than genuine enthusiasm for Reform or Green policies.

A vote for the Greens has become, effectively, a nihilistic howl of left-wing rage. The party’s views on everything from Gaza, to gender, to taxes are positively unhinged.

Meanwhile, the likely effects on the Union of Reform UK’s success are more significant and uncertain.

The party is officially unionist, as emphasised by Danny Kruger and Robert Jenrick on recent visits to Northern Ireland. But in Scotland, it encouraged nationalists to support its candidates, on the basis that a Reform government would get the country ‘match fit’ for independence.

This may have been a clever tactic, but it will have worried unionists who were already wary of its leader, Nigel Farage.

Their apprehensions might be justified, but Reform savaged Labour in its traditional heartlands, and its ascent shows no signs of peaking.

Pro-Union parties need to think about how they can strengthen Northern Ireland’s position in the UK under a Farage government, rather than pre-judging the prospect as a disaster.

Meanwhile, the nationalist challenge across Britain remains dangerous, but it can be managed. Of course, separatists are still in the business of trying to destroy the UK. But despite their boasts they are no closer, yet, to breaking up the world’s most enduring, successful political Union.

To make sure that remains the case, we need ministers at Westminster to stop pandering to the UK’s enemies within, whoever ends up occupying Number 10.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice