Phelim McAleer: To win the war with Iran, US must have the courage and self-belief to be committed to defeating the enemy - radical Islam

​So, will America win this war? That’s the only question worth asking right now. It seems that since World War II, America has become spectacularly bad at winning wars. From Korea to Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan, it can fight with all the shock and awe on the planet but always eventually loses.

A plume of smoke rises after a strike in Tehran, Iran earlier this week. (Picture: AP/Mohsen Ganji)placeholder image
A plume of smoke rises after a strike in Tehran, Iran earlier this week. (Picture: AP/Mohsen Ganji)

​This has traumatised the American establishment and pleased the radical left in the country, who hate America and like to see it lose no matter how bad or repressive the enemy is.

But this is President Trump. He doesn’t hate America and has no qualms about using America’s power when he needs to. Can he win? To do so, he needs to learn the lessons of the recent conflicts.

It is often said that bad generals are excellent at fighting the last war. They absorb and implement the lessons from the previous conflict without realising that the world, technology, politics and their enemy are now different - and once again they lose.

That has been the American way recently. Will Trump follow this pattern?

First of all, he has to be honest about why America has lost all those wars. It wasn’t because of technology or any lack of bravery and commitment from its armed forces.

America lost these wars because many of those giving the orders in Washington no longer believe in America or that American values are worth fighting for. They also no longer believe in good and evil.

So you can invade Afghanistan and Iraq, win the initial battles, take over the country, and then watch those gains mean nothing as you suffer a war of attrition against an enemy that doesn’t fear you - or death.

And you eventually lose. But you really lose because you fail to realise that you were not fighting the people of Afghanistan or Iraq, or even their inferior weapons. You were actually fighting radical Islamism.

It doesn’t matter whether it’s Republicans or Democrats fighting the wars. If you adopt the “Islam is a religion of peace” attitude, then you will never succeed. George Bush started the rot in the days after 9/11 by issuing that very phrase. At the time it was viewed as a harmless platitude that made Bush look good and assuaged America’s then-small Muslim population. But it became a blueprint for war. The idea was that America would defeat the soldiers and woo the populations, who were supposedly just like us and longed to become American if given the chance.

So America went off to Afghanistan and Iraq with what broadcaster Mark Steyn has labelled the ‘Three Cups of Tea’ plan: get to know the locals (by spending time with them and drinking the said cups of Tetley) and win them over by spending money and improving their lives.

Unfortunately, this mostly entailed building mosques and schools where children could be ‘educated’ to hate America even more than their parents did.

The ludicrous strategy came out of the experience of mountaineer and charity worker Greg Mortenson, whose memoir Three Cups of Tea described how he was kidnapped by Pakistani militants in the mid-90s and, through sharing lots of cuppas, gained their respect and ended up funding a school in their village - that resulted in enduring friendships.

According to the Washington Post, the book was “touted by top commanders and devoured by younger officers” looking for a way to win the interminable wars they were fighting.

That anyone ever believed the Three Cups of Tea story is a sign of just how far and deep the leftist penetration of America’s military and political establishment has gone.

The idea that we just need to talk to radical Islamists and we will find common ground and live happily ever after is a very enticing fairytale.

Then the US investigative TV programme 60 Minutes found the Three Cups of Tea story to be an actual fairytale - a hoax. There was no kidnapping, no growing respect, and not even a school built as a result. It was all made up.

To win the war with Iran, America needs to know that its enemy is radical Islam and be committed to defeating that enemy.

It is lucky in one respect: Iran is not Afghanistan or Iraq. This is not the last war. The people are more open to America and the West. They are an ancient culture that predates Islam. There is no Sunni/Shia split in the country to fuel unrest and a low-level civil war.

America needs to treat Islamist Iran the way it treated Nazi Germany (one of the last wars it won). Germany was deNazified. They were clear - Nazism was evil and its leaders were imprisoned or executed. Do Americans have the courage and self-belief to do that in Iran?

​

l Phelim McAleer is a Co Tyrone born producer/journalist living in Los Angeles. @PhelimMcAleer

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice