Ruth Dudley Edwards: Dilemma for Ireland as it is faces a clash between looking after its economic interests and obeying EU

​Ireland is assuming the EU council presidency on July 1 for six months for what may become a very embarrassing term of office.

Taoiseach Micheal Martin’s line is that sanctioning the plant ‘would harm Europe much more than Russia’placeholder image
Taoiseach Micheal Martin’s line is that sanctioning the plant ‘would harm Europe much more than Russia’

Used to being the EU’s smiled upon Best Boy in the Class, Ireland is a grateful recipient of largesse, eloquent in its loyalty to the institution and prepared to go along with slightly unwelcome demands with a modest bribe here or there.

For sceptical onlookers with a sense of history, it’s been fascinating to see how the Irish have been bragging for a century about their struggle for independence, while at every turn happily surrendering sovereignty to an unelected bureaucracy.

This involves quite a bit of dissimulation as they have to juggle loyalties to what the country still hangs on to as the sacred principal of neutrality, while taking in many thousands of Ukrainian refugees and supplying vast amounts of aid other than weapons.

The scandal that is at last being exposed is the little matter of Ireland’s seemingly covert help for Russia for economic reasons in the war against Ukraine, which is being unmasked by, among others, a principled young Irishman called Caolan Robertson.

Robertson left Kilkenny for the UK when he was 13 with his father, dabbled as a teenager with what he describes as a far-right cult and then became wedded to investigative journalism and the cause of Ukraine, where he’s lived since 2024.

He was a key figure in revealing that the refinery Aughinish Alumina, a Limerick-based plant, was shipping huge amounts of alumina to smelters in Russia where it makes aluminium, a vital ingredient for arms manufacturers.

The EU has so far avoided sanctioning alumina, but as this comes out into the open, the commission is caught between members like Estonia who want the EU to apply its anti-Russian sanctions to Aughinish products and Irish politicians who dread hundreds of job losses in Limerick and serious damage to supply chains.

At home, Sinn Fein are taking a preposterous high moral line on arms supply of any kind; the public remain very keen on Ukraine but equally keen on being neutral; and the Irish government faces a serious clash between economic interests and obeying the commission.

The taoiseach’s line is that sanctioning the plant “would be harming Europe much more than Russia”.

The EU has obligingly charged Ireland to carry out an investigation into claims that products from the refinery — which is owned by a Russian parent company — are being used to supply arms manufacturers.

Irish strategy when it comes to knotty moral problems has been mainly to reach for the weapon of strategic ambiguity which has served it so well.

But Robertson has posted on X that he’s managed to sneak two samples of Aughinish Alumina powder out of Ireland for testing.

“It’s from two sources: at the refinery and from a worker who doesn’t want to be identified.

“He told me the biggest threat to his job is Russian ownership and he wants it exposed & nationalised.”

There are no easy ways out of this and it’s just one of several dilemmas facing Ireland at every turn.

Whatever you say about politics these days, it’s not boring.

Ruth Dudley Edwards’ books include The Faithful Tribe: An Intimate Portrait of the Loyal Institutions and The Omagh Bombing and the Families’ Pursuit of Justice

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice