Jackie McGregor: “Never meet your heroes”: Jagger, Lennon, Elvis and my TV cop crush
“Never meet your heroes” was the advice John Lennon once gave Rolling Stones frontman Mick Jagger.
On a recent podcast, Jagger, now in his eighties, said Lennon had warned him years ago against meeting Elvis Presley and he now bitterly regretted taking that advice.


Lennon tried to put Mick off because he didn’t want him to repeat the Beatles’ own awkward encounter with ‘The King’. They had arrived at Presley’s house thrilled to meet their idol, only to sit through a tense, silent gathering. The Fab Four were so awestruck they couldn’t think of anything to say to ‘The Pelvis,’ who seemed to be having a rare charisma-free evening.
Presley finally broke the silence by telling them that, if they were just going to stare at him, he was going to bed. Lennon came away from the meeting completely disillusioned, while Elvis seemed to take against John so strongly that he later turned up at the White House unannounced, asked to see President Nixon, and accused the Beatles of stirring up anti-American feeling.
Yikes! No wonder Lennon told Jagger to let Elvis be.
Sometimes it’s better to keep the perfect version of your hero safely tucked away in your head, untouched by real life, something I learned the hard way with my own hero.
He was an Adonis: tall, muscular, platinum blond, and one half of Starsky and Hutch. In my early teens, I lived for Saturday nights when actor David Soul would appear on TV and melt my heart. My crush lasted years; I even dreamed of becoming the sixth Mrs Soul.
As fate would have it, our paths crossed when I was working on a celebrity charity book for Alzheimer’s.
He was the one celebrity I most wanted to recruit - and I got him. He was utterly charming, sent me a beautifully written piece, and we discussed Alzheimer’s and his family’s experience of it. He gave me his personal mobile number. I sat there holding it but couldn’t quite work up the nerve to call (thankfully!) Then a renowned author friend, who regularly dealt with celebrities and charity projects, urged me: “Ask him if any of his celebrity friends would like to contribute too.”
Warning bells rang in my head, this was very much not my style. But she goaded me on, and with her experience of dealing with stars, I foolishly thought this must be the done thing. Big mistake!
Upon asking him about his “celeb” friends’ possible help, all hell broke loose. Lovely David evaporated and the polar opposite emerged. He replied with a vile email containing a long-winded, defensive tirade, questioning, “what even is celebrity?”
I squirmed reading it. I appeared to have touched several nerves. The pedestal didn’t just crack, it shattered. My memory of my late former hero was tarnished forever. Years later he publicly admitted to having anger issues. No kidding Dave!
Mick Jagger might have done himself a favour giving Elvis a miss. Our heroes are generally not the flawless idols we build up in our minds. They’re simply humans with anxieties, boundaries and touchy subjects of their own. Sometimes it’s kinder to leave them safely in that space between reality and our dreams, or in my case, preferably trapped inside a 1970s TV screen, where they can’t email you back.