Economists: Sinn Fein minister has used economic data that disguises the recent slow growth of Northern Ireland’s exports, and so seems to be boosting the impact of the Irish Sea border
A letter from Dr Graham Gudgin and Dr Esmond Birnie:


In the several decades that we have been working with Northern Ireland’s economic data we have always been impressed with its accuracy and transparency.
The civil servants involved have been diligent and honest. It is thus a disappointment that a recent economic press release from the Department for the Economy appears to introduce a degree of deception.
The press release (‘Minister welcomes latest Economic Output figures for the north’ on the Department of Economy website, January 15) provides up to date statistics on economic growth in the year to the third quarter of 2025. Sinn Fein economy minister, Dr Caoimhe Archibald, said that “the north’s” output grew faster than in Great Britain and earnings and exports also performed relatively well.


The accompanying figures showed output and earnings growing faster than in GB over the year. However, when it came to the sensitive export figures, the press release gave figures for a two-year period rather than the latest year which was used for output and earnings. Why should this be so?
The obvious reason was that over the latest year exports from Northern Ireland grew more slowly than in GB, despite the negative impact of oil exports in GB and the boost to NI exports from electricity trading. His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) has indicated it is likely to revise upwards its recorded growth of GB oil and gas exports for 2025 which will mean that Northern Ireland’s export growth will be further behind GB in the revised data.
The press release thus disguises the recent slow growth of Northern Ireland’s exports. This is a sensitive matter due the controversy over the Northern Ireland Protocol/ Windsor Framework. Sinn Fein is on the side of those who wish to demonstrate that NI has the best of both worlds from these arrangements.
Slow growth in exports is thus something of an embarrassment and the suspicion is that civil servants have been prevailed upon to disguise the recent unfavourable trend. We can also add that caution should be used in comparing NI’s export figures with those of GB since unlike in GB NI’s figures for trade with the EU come not from UK sources as is the case with GB but from the EU, and involve complications due to exchange rate.
In addition, the figures showing faster growth in Northern Ireland’s output in the latest year may not be reliable. The Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency’s Composite Economic Index which is used to measure output is highly volatile and generally agreed to not be entirely comparable to the Office for National Statistics’ data on UK GDP growth.
Dr Graham Gudgin CBE, Centre for Business Research, University of Cambridge, Dr Esmond Birnie, Senior Economist at Ulster University