Letter: Allow the law to take its course at Drumcree - you can disagree with a decision, but you are not entitled to prevent it from being carried out
A letter from Jamie Clough:


The Drumcree dispute has never been just a matter of a parade but an issue of 30 years of concern and community division.
However, as the recent dispute has progressed, I ask a bigger question: what does the rule of law mean when we disagree with the outcome?
The Parades Commission is responsible for dealing with all marches in Northern Ireland. In this case, they considered the application and allowed a more limited march than was originally wanted. Conditions were put in place to balance the rights and interests of those taking part with those living along the route.


If people believe a decision made by the Parades Commission to be wrong, they have the legal right to challenge it in court. However, when the courts upheld the Parades Commission’s decision, there has to be a point where, even if you disagree with an outcome, you must accept it.
Article 11 of the ECHR sets out the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly. However, in the case of Drumcree, there is a clear difference between peacefully protesting a parade and physically preventing it from taking place.
Those protesting on the Garvaghy Road have every right to be angry and make their views known, given the history of Drumcree; it would be wrong to pretend their concerns appeared out of nowhere.
However, blocking the road to stop a legally authorised march is a different matter. You can disagree with a decision, but you are not entitled to prevent it from being carried out.
If everyone could block a road whenever they disagreed with a decision, the legal process would be all but meaningless.
That does not mean that the concerns of residents should be ignored. The history of Drumcree means that this parade carries significance far beyond the route it takes.
People living along the Garvaghy Road have genuine concerns, and those concerns deserve to be heard. However, listening to those concerns is not the same as giving anyone a veto.
The right to protest belongs to those opposing the march, just as the right to peaceful assembly belongs to those taking part.
Neither side should have the ability to completely override the other. That is why the legal process exists, to balance out these rights and interests.
For that reason, I believe that the march should be allowed to proceed under the conditions set by the Parades Commission, peacefully and lawfully.
The rule of law does not mean always getting your own way; it means accepting that there are rules and processes for resolving disagreements, even when we do not like the outcome.
If the law only matters when we agree with it, ultimately it does not matter at all.
Jamie Clough, Law student, Queen's University Belfast