Letter: Arlene Foster's rise and fall serves as a key lesson for unionism - the Union is safe if there is a positive leader and a positive vision
A letter from Edward Ferrin:


This month marks 10 years since Arlene Foster became the leader of the DUP at the end of 2015.
Her tenure serves as a stark lesson for unionism. Many of us had hope that Arlene Foster would be Northern Ireland’s (and unionism’s) answer to Scotland’s Nicola Sturgeon.
Indeed, Arlene was a highly intelligent and competent politician and was clearly the best candidate to replace Peter Robinson in 2015. She will always be the first female first minister of Northern Ireland – no one can ever take away that monumental achievement.


The party would not have overcome the strong challenge from Mike Nesbitt and the UUP in 2016 had Arlene Foster not been chosen. Do you remember the infamous ‘Keep Arlene first minister’ election campaign from 2016?
Arlene Foster was the driving force behind the DUP’s victory – unionism was stronger than ever before.
The key lesson for unionism? The Union is safe if there is a positive leader and a positive vision that could break down electoral barriers.
The RHI scandal broke the momentum for Arlene Foster and the DUP. The 2017 assembly election was a disaster. Arlene’s infamous ‘if you feed a crocodile’ remarks were a huge vote winner for Sinn Féin, who used that one line to come within one seat of winning the position of first minister.
With 10 MPs in the House of Commons after Theresa May’s miscalculation in the June Westminster election, the DUP’s focus turned to Westminster, not Stormont. Arlene Foster’s leadership was by then already under increasing pressure.
Within just 18 months after the 2016 election, Arlene Foster was now a leader of the DUP from an assembly that wasn't functioning.
Her leadership through the Brexit negotiations was dogged by a serious miscalculation on the Irish Sea border – delivered by a Conservative government which the DUP propped up for two years.
When the DUP lost the balance of power in London, it came back into an executive just as Covid-19 took over. Arlene Foster returned to a glimpse of what she showed back in 2016 – a leader who could deliver when we needed it most. Arlene Foster jointly navigated the executive through the pandemic, the protocol protests and the Bobby Storey controversy. Her fall from the DUP leadership in 2021 provoked similarities with Margaret Thatcher’s demise in 1990.
Many will look back at Arlene Foster’s tenure as DUP leader and first minister with a sense of what could have been. She made a positive contribution to NI, but she could have done more or handled issues differently. She was a trailblazer, she could be a leader in times of crisis and for that she alone should be very proud. She was a popular leader when she took charge.
However, she made mistakes and never recovered from them - to the detriment of her party and of unionism. Pro-Union politics in NI has never fully recovered from the Foster era - a sign that a huge vacuum has remained since her departure.
Maybe one day Arlene will follow Nicola Sturgeon and personally explore her time as DUP leader and first minister by putting pen to paper with her very own memoir.
Edward Ferrin, Belfast BT14