Letter: Ben Lowry did not take account of key facts in his critique of public sector pensions

A letter from Frank McClintock:

To say that I am annoyed by Ben Lowry's recent article on the subject of public sector pensions (‘The cost to taxpayers of lavish public sector pensions in Northern Ireland is a looming scandal,’ September 7) would be an understatement.

Letters to editorplaceholder image
Letters to editor

He obviously wrote the article from a place of either absolute or wilful ignorance, which takes not account of the following facts:

1. Public sector pay is and always has been calculated taking full account of the significant benefit conferred by the defined benefit pension schemes. That is why the salaries of (particularly) middle and senior management come nowhere near levels in the private sector. In addition, the state pension for all employees is reduced as they were contracted out of the various additional state pension schemes.

2. Both the UK and NI governments have made significant changes to the pension schemes since 2008 to make them more sustainable for the future, increasing the contribution rates (now average 8.5%) from much lower levels, increasing the normal retirement age to align with the state pension (now 66 and increasing) and moving to career average rather than final salary . These changes have made the overall cost to the public purse potentially much lower in future, from 2% of GDP to about 1.5% in 30 years.

3. The average public service pension for the vast majority after a full career of over 40 years is between £15,000 and £20,000 per year. This is hardly lavish and is significantly under the level for a comfortable retirement which is about £39,000 per year.

The public service provides an essential role in running the country which would be sorely missed.

Long term and loyal employees deserve a decent retirement in which they do not have to claim benefits (other than the state pension) like so many private sector retirees who do not receive a decent pension due to private sector greed and illegal plundering of their pension schemes and the need to satisfy demanding and greedy shareholders.

Frank McClintock, Lisburn

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice