Letter: DUP decline stretches back further than last election, and 2027 is lining up to be the year when it could emerge as a defeated party
A letter from Edward Ferrin:


David Trimble lost the 2005 Westminster election in Upper Bann.
Peter Robinson said on the day of the election: “Slowly and surely he has been brought to account.”
He led the UUP to electoral decline after taking political risks when he agreed to the Good Friday Agreement and power-sharing.


Who would have thought that the party who so jubilantly celebrated the demise of David Trimble and the UUP would now be facing a similar fate?
The DUP is in crisis. The long list of problems facing the party since 2021 has been loaded with yet more questions and issues arising from the Donaldson scandal.
For a party that has been kept alive by electoral resuscitation each time it has faced challenges, the DUP has lost its place as the dominant electoral force it once was over recent years.
This has a huge impact on how the DUP will fare over the coming months and years.
The decline of the UUP in 2005 was not spontaneous. It happened over a long period. The UUP lost support in 1998 and continually declined in the polls up to 2005.
The DUP has also not spontaneously declined or combusted in a short space of time. If you look back at events over the past 16 years, you will see the signs of the DUP’s eventual decline.
Peter Robinson’s defeat in the 2010 Westminster election to Naomi Long was an early warning sign. So too were the 2012 Union Flag protests.
The tragedy for unionism has been the fact that the DUP’s skill to put short-term electoral gain ahead of long-term strategy helped ensure there was no credible alternative from the UUP or TUV to replace them as the largest party.
The rallying cry to “keep Sinn Féin out” was useful in shoring up support for the DUP when unionists began to feel their voice wasn’t heard in the corridors of power.
The last Assembly election changed that. The DUP lost out in seats and votes to Sinn Féin.
The party is no longer the habitual election winner it was and now finds itself in a dangerous position as the second largest party across Northern Ireland, but still the largest unionist party.
The DUP is no longer a safe bet to keep Sinn Féin out, which now changes the psychology of the unionist electorate – they no longer feel obliged to vote for the DUP as they had done previously.
Next May’s election is as much a significant election for unionism as the 2005 Westminster election. At his eventual electoral defeat, David Trimble said that the DUP will know that “with…success comes responsibility”.
Many feel the DUP has shirked its responsibility as the largest unionist party for far too long but has never felt electoral consequences for its short-termism.
This time, with a rejuvenated UUP under Jon Burrows and a solid electoral profile behind Jim Allister’s TUV, 2027 is lining up to be the year when the DUP could emerge as a defeated party, a spent force and a liability to the Union.
The DUP has never in its history lost so much power as it could next May – such a scenario could threaten the party’s future.
Edward Ferrin, Belfast BT14