Letter: Here’s how to avoid the break-up of the UK - take measures that signal the presence of an effective state

A letter from John Gemmell:

Former UK health secretary Wes Streeting seems best placed to pick up the piecesplaceholder image
Former UK health secretary Wes Streeting seems best placed to pick up the pieces

The UK is struggling. I am not advocating returning to the EU, but we have to do something.

I, like most people, have a few ideas. But first, I want to summarise the last 10 years as I see them.

Brexit failed, it triggered mass immigration and, importantly, on-going economic underperformance. We replaced young single European migrants, who often later returned home, with Africans and Asians who stayed permanently and often brought their families with them.

Letter to the editorplaceholder image
Letter to the editor

Hostility to the EU, and perceived integration problems with some non-European newcomers, fuelled support for Reform UK and caused huge divisions in our politics. Brexit itself, and its ensuing chaos and drift, fuelled separatism and nationalism, now even in Wales.

At the same time, the effects of Brexit sapped the energy of the political class, both right and left. Afraid of the kind of analysis that I have just offered, it cast around for partial solutions. We got sticking plasters not strategies. Politicians struggled with issues of growth and EU links, fairness for the less well-off, separatism and immigration control. Covid and president Trump did not help. Politics was and is paralysed.

So, what is to be done? Four things, I think. Some policies would appeal to the left, some to the right. As a joint programme it would either unite most people or be rejected by everyone!

Former UK health secretary Wes Streeting, certainly not Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham, seems best placed to pick up the pieces. Streeting would not share my take on immigration, but I was pleased to see, in his recent resignation letter, that he recognises the direct threat of nationalism and the need for an ambitious approach to government. I think:-

We should rejoin the EU customs union and get as close to the EU single market as possible, without accepting full freedom of movement of people. But we should accept free movement for EU students and young people while excluding most from elsewhere. Better EU alignment should boost growth and help tackle the Irish Sea border. Let's not worry about being ‘rule-takers’ at this stage. We have other problems;

We should further reduce non-EU immigration;

When the Ukraine war is over, we need an enhanced European security architecture with us at the core;

Crucially, we should refocus expenditure on helping workers on modest incomes and also young people. Why not free bus passes for everyone under 35, paid for by expanding North Sea oil and gas production? Why not nationalise electricity and reduce bills dramatically, paid for by the extra growth that would come from closer EU ties? Why not build millions of Housing Association homes, paid for by savings from parts of the welfare budget and by borrowing to invest?

Measures like this should avoid the break-up of the UK as they would signal the presence of an effective state. The key concern here is not Northern Ireland, where experienced voters understand the consequences of bad decisions. It is Scotland. On the mainland, we tend to take things for granted, leading to inevitable mistakes - which brings us back to Brexit.

John Gemmell, Wem, Shropshire

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice