Letter: Instead of arguing about the ‘call-in’ process Belfast City Council should adopt the less adversarial and more accurate system of preferential voting

A letter from Dr Peter Emerson:

One of the first people to realise that majority voting has its limitations was Pliny the Younger in ancient Rome in the year 105.

Belfast City Council's debates about voting systems are stuck in the 2,000-year-old binary grooveplaceholder image
Belfast City Council's debates about voting systems are stuck in the 2,000-year-old binary groove

Hence plurality voting, as in the Danish parliament. And the first to devise a preferential form of multi-option voting, a points system, was Nicholas of Cusa in 1433.

Sadly, Belfast City Council’s current arguments about the ‘call-in’ process are all still stuck in the 2,000-year-old binary groove. As the New Ireland Group demonstrated to the DUP, Sinn Fein, and everyone else in 1986, however, preferential voting can be far less adversarial and far more accurate.

Letters to editorplaceholder image
Letters to editor

Instead of reducing everything to one or more two-option votes, in which some vote ‘yes’ and others ‘no’, it is wiser to aim for just one or two six-option ballots in which voters vote either ‘yes’ for their favourite, or, in their order of preference ‘yes’ for a few options, but in which NO-ONE VOTES ‘NO’!

This methodology, the Modified Borda Count MBC or Borda préférendum, devised in 1770 by Jean-Charles de Borda and then adopted by the French Academy of Sciences, was rejected by he who had no time for this ‘consensus voting’ - one Napoléon Bonaparte.

It was also dismissed at a role-play presented by this Institute to the Belfast City Council’s Policy and Resources Committee in 2004 (the web version of this letter will link to it at http://www.deborda.org/belfast-city-council-role-pl/ )

Despite the role-play showing the MBC to be most accurate, it was indeed dismissed, largely because ‘these ’uns’ didn’t want to be in consensus with ‘them ’uns’.

Dr Peter Emerson, The de Borda Institute, Belfast BT14

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice