Letter: Weak leadership of unionism threatens another own goal
A letter from Edward Ferrin:


Whether or not you agree the Orange Order should walk down the Garvaghy Road doesn’t change the fact that the events in Portadown recently have handed Sinn Féin a huge electoral opportunity to make votes out of nationalist anger over the Drumcree parade.
Things are not helped also when we see unionism led by a weak DUP leadership who are scrambling for anything to avert its electoral decline.
Any unionist politician with a political brain (very rare it seems these days) should see that no matter if we agree with the right of the Garvaghy Road residents to be angered or not, it is clear there is a strong feeling of anger among Irish nationalists.


An angry nationalist electorate will mobilise in the upcoming elections – making it much more difficult for unionism to defeat Sinn Féin in May’s elections.
Unionism has declined consistently since the DUP replaced the UUP as the leading unionist party in 2003. The number of strategic mistakes has grown since then also.
The devolution of policing and justice, Brexit, support for Boris Johnson’s government, reducing MLAs from 108 to 90 and collapsing Stormont in 2022. Mistake after mistake, own goal after own goal.
Unionism can’t continue making strategic errors and scoring electoral own goals because it could one day wake up and realise it has sleepwalked itself into a united Ireland because it didn’t change course before it was too late. The DUP has been responsible for each of them.
Unionist voters must reflect on the DUP’s time as the largest party within unionism and ask themselves a fundamental question: has the DUP weakened or strengthened nationalism and Sinn Féin? Undoubtedly the DUP has strengthened nationalism and Sinn Féin. Michelle O’Neill’s party won 23.5% of the vote in 2003 but got 29% in 2022. Unionism had 50.6% of the vote in 2003, but only 42.2% in 2022.
What the past couple of weeks should tell all unionists who wish to avoid such another scenario where unionism hands Sinn Féin another gift is that the DUP mustn’t collapse the Executive. It would be electorally disastrous if Emma Little-Pengelly resigned as deputy first minister. Another DUP collapse of Stormont would only entrench nationalist anger against unionism and boost Sinn Féin’s attempts to divert attention away from their failures in government.
However, the DUP have a great skill in doing what most helps Sinn Féin electorally. It seems there are too many voices within the party and within the unionist/loyalist commentary determined to do just that again.
This is a challenge for Gavin Robinson over the coming weeks. Is he going to finally stamp his authority as the leader of political unionism and not hand Sinn Féin another PR victory or will he continue to be led by vocal minorities within unionism who are taking advantage of a divided and weakened DUP and who are leading unionism further and further down the road to a united Ireland?
He now has to choose – he can’t hide from it any longer. Unionism is in the mess it finds itself in now because Gavin Robinson and his predecessors have dithered when we need strong leadership, but is he a strong leader? Time will tell.
Edward Ferrin, Belfast BT14