Mary Lou McDonald is as entitled to think of Ireland as a single nation as I, an Englishman, am to think of England that way

How dare the Belfast News Letter publish a letter characterising Mary Lou McDonald TD (Sinn Fein) as expressing ‘incoherent babbling nonsense’ (April 29).
The Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald is an English graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, which Dr Morgan, a TCD fellow, describes as "the great university of All-Ireland, founded by Elizabeth I in 1592, and the equal of Oxford and Cambridge"The Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald is an English graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, which Dr Morgan, a TCD fellow, describes as "the great university of All-Ireland, founded by Elizabeth I in 1592, and the equal of Oxford and Cambridge"
The Sinn Fein president Mary Lou McDonald is an English graduate of Trinity College, Dublin, which Dr Morgan, a TCD fellow, describes as "the great university of All-Ireland, founded by Elizabeth I in 1592, and the equal of Oxford and Cambridge"

(The letter can be read in full here: ‘Mary Lou McDonald talking like Trump’).

Such intemperate abuse helps no one on the island of Ireland.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mary Lou McDonald TD (Dublin Central, 11,223 first preference votes) read English I and II in Trinity College Dublin in the late 1980s. This course was the successor to English Language and Literature.

Letter to the editorLetter to the editor
Letter to the editor

After the removal of Latin as an entrance requirement for English in Trinity in the early 1970s the Department of English was divided into two departments, English I (Medieval and Renaissance English) and English II (Modern English).

In that way we have preserved in Trinity College Dublin, the great university of All-Ireland (founded by Elizabeth I in 1592) and the equal of Oxford and Cambridge, the study of Old English Literature and particularly Beowulf (and the whole of Beowulf in the original Anglian dialect).

Indeed, as for the ignoramuses at Cambridge, they still seem to think that English literature begins with the Norman Conquest.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Surely Mary Lou McDonald is as entitled to think of Ireland as a single nation as I, an Englishman, think of England as a united nation, even though under British rule from incompetent Tories at Westminster.

Disagree with her by all means in the Belfast News Letter. But she is an eloquent representative of a political opinion shared by a majority of the Irish people, today as at all times in Irish history.

But please treat her with respect.

Dr Gerald Morgan, Fellow of Trinity College Dublin, Leader English Parliamentary Party, 2001