London has a duty to balance legacy investigation into claims against the state, including the millions spent on the Finucane case

The loyalist murder of Pat Finucane at his family dinner table in 1989 was grievous crime.
News Letter editorialNews Letter editorial
News Letter editorial

Given that he was a lawyer and that there was some state collusion in the case, it has been the subject of probes costing millions, including by the policeman John Stevens and the globally respected human rights lawyer Sir Desmond de Silva.

He was appointed after campaigners for a public inquiry rejected one being held under the 2005 Inquiries Act.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The prime minister David Cameron apologised after his report, which found no over-arching conspiracy.

But demands grow for millions more to be spent on this one Troubles killing. Dublin, Irish opposition parties, Alliance, and now the Labour Party have joined a republican call for, in effect, this case to be singled out for scrutiny.

It is grinding its way through the courts again, even though the Supreme Court said recently it was up to the UK whether or not to hold an inquiry.

Judges said no probe compliant with Article Two of the human rights convention had been held into Finucane, despite millions spent. This was wrongly reported as a court order for a probe.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

No government could meet more than a fraction of the need to get truth and justice for the 3,700 Troubles dead.

Yet the handling of the Finucane case illustrates the legacy imbalance, as William Matchett says on page 19 (see link below), and other voices such as Kate Hoey have also said this week.

It would be madness to spend vast sums on the past in a financial crisis. But if London goes down this road it will be an outrage if it does not open multiple probes into IRA terrorism including one into their murder of judges and lawyers.

READ MORE ON THIS TOPIC:

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Our journalism costs money and we rely on advertising, print and digital revenues to help to support them. By supporting us, we are able to support you in providing trusted, fact-checked content for this website.

Alistair Bushe

Editor