Peter Robinson: Respect for each other’s cultures and traditions must be a two-way street
At the beginning of August, I stayed away from the centre of my own city.
For a week, its streets and public spaces were given over to a celebration of a culture that, apart from a few exceptions, is not my own.


The Belfast Fleadh brought a week of what the organisers described as the largest celebration of Irish music and culture. Many others from my tradition also gave the city centre a wide berth.
Some unionists, more curious than I was, went along to see what it was all about. Thousands from the nationalist community took part in their festival of Irish music and culture in Belfast's shared streets.


I did not complain.
The new dispensation in Northern Ireland requires us to respect other people’s culture, not merely our own. That is how a genuinely shared society works. It is a two-way process – or at least it is supposed to be.
Unionists passed that test. They did not unlawfully interfere with, or attempt to disrupt, a legally organised cultural event. Some even participated.
Then the Parades Commission authorised a small number of Orangemen to walk a short distance along a traditional route their fathers and grandfathers had travelled. The determination was challenged in the courts, but the court declined to overturn it.
The conditions were stringent: no more than 35 people on the parade; no accompanying supporters; no bands; no flags; no stoppages. All of this would take only about 20 minutes to pass the nationalist estate.
The spin and hype from the republican spokespersons were without bounds. The people of Garvaghy Road are “terrified”, according to Sinn Fein MP John Finucane.
Just imagine, the thousands of people in the Garvaghy Road area are quivering and terrified because a few dozen people walk down the road at 8am, accompanied by the police. Come off it. Grow up. Such absurd remarks will not hide or validate the unlawful behaviour by republicans that followed.
The question was therefore simple. Having seen unionists accommodate a major nationalist cultural event in the heart of the city for an entire week, would nationalists reciprocate by tolerating a small, tightly restricted and lawfully authorised Orange Order parade?
If Sinn Fein and the SDLP represent the nationalist community – and I have to assume they do – then the answer is no.
Republicans came from every part of the province and beyond to be offended by a small group walking down the road or, more accurately, to stop them no matter what the consequences might be.
Mary Lou McDonald came from the Republic of Ireland to protest against a lawful determination concerning a road in Northern Ireland and to insist she would not ever allow those she disapproved of to ever walk down this road.
Whatever political objections Sinn Fein had to the parade, the proper place to pursue them was through the lawful processes available – not by frustrating a determination once those processes had run their course.
This matters far beyond one parade on one road.
Northern Ireland now has an Assembly and Executive supposedly committed to equality, fairness, shared space and cultural parity. Those principles are meaningful only if they apply when it is difficult to accommodate someone else.
We were therefore entitled to expect leadership from the first minister, especially one who describes herself as a first minister for all.
At a minimum, that should have meant urging everyone to remain calm, uphold the law, preserve the peace and respect the lawful determination, even if some continued to express disagreement peacefully.
Instead, Michelle O’Neill participated in the most grotesque abrogation of ministerial responsibility possible.
Far from an example of how to conduct herself peacefully and provide leadership in a divided society, we saw brazen, partisan, unlawful activity – worse, we saw her encourage others to join her in breaking the law.
This demonstrates a visceral hatred of other cultures and, by extension, other communities.
The conduct of the first minister and her elected colleagues, in my view, crossed the line into unlawful obstruction and incitement. If any office-holder encouraged others to break the law, that raises questions considerably more serious than the merits of this particular parade.
It raises questions about ministerial responsibility, the Pledge of Office, the Ministerial Code, Assembly and Local Government Standards – it should trigger investigations and, ultimately, legal proceedings.
Those questions must now be answered through the proper legal and constitutional processes.
The next few weeks will test everyone.
Unionists should show forbearance. The Orange Order, in relation to this dispute, need do nothing beyond continuing to comply with the lawful determination.
The wider unionist community should watch carefully to see how the United Kingdom government, the police, prosecutors and the courts respond.
The central question is whether Northern Ireland operates under one law, applied equally to everyone.
That principle cannot depend upon whether those accused of breaking the law are republican or loyalist, nationalist or unionist, minister or ordinary citizen.
There should therefore be a proper investigation of any elected representative reasonably suspected of unlawful conduct.
Where councillors may have breached their obligations, the appropriate standards procedures should be invoked. Where Assembly Members are alleged to have breached applicable standards, those allegations should be examined through the Assembly’s processes.
Where ministers are alleged to have breached the Ministerial Code or the Pledge of Office, the relevant accountability mechanisms should be pursued.
If the Assembly’s cross-community voting mechanism is used to block punishment, HMG must bring forward legislation to establish a quasi-judicial body outside the Assembly to adjudicate such matters independently.
And where there is evidence that any person committed a criminal offence – whether by obstruction, public-order offending or unlawful incitement – the police and Public Prosecution Service should deal with that evidence in precisely the same way they would if the political identities were reversed. If they do not, then law and order will suffer.
That last point is particularly important for the PSNI.
Public confidence in policing depends not simply on enforcing the law, but on the public believing it will be enforced consistently.
If republican protestors are treated differently from loyalist protestors engaging in similar conduct, confidence in impartial policing will inevitably suffer. The same, of course, would be true in reverse.
Northern Ireland has learned at considerable cost how difficult political institutions are to build, and how easily confidence in them can be destroyed.
My concern is therefore larger than the Garvaghy Road. I want a genuinely shared society, with institutions that people from every tradition can subscribe to and uphold.
Such a society cannot survive on selective tolerance: one community demanding respect for its culture while denying another equivalent respect. Nor can political institutions command confidence if those entrusted with administering them appear willing to disregard the legal framework when a lawful decision goes against them.
Sinn Fein and the first minister should consider the consequences of their actions carefully and step back from any activity that obstructs a lawful parade. Unionists, meanwhile, should resist the temptation to respond in kind.
The state and its processes must now do their job.
Any alleged offences should be investigated impartially.
Any sanctions should follow evidence, due process and the law – not political pressure or communal identity.
That is the test.
Not whether we agree with the Orange Order. Not whether we agree with Sinn Fein. Not whether we like a particular parade or dislike the road along which it travels.
The test of a shared society is whether we uphold the rights of people whose traditions are not our own, and whether the same law applies when it is politically inconvenient to us.
Unionists accepted that principle in August.
They are entitled to expect it in return.