‘Freemasonry is far too good an organisation to die, it’ll keep going’

​​From secret handshakes to initiation ceremonies, the Freemasons have been steeped in myths and legends for hundreds of years.

In a rare new interview, renowned broadcaster Donna Traynor has spoken with a senior member of the organisation in Northern Ireland and quizzed him about some of the preconceptions the public hold.

John Edens, the Provincial Grand Master of the Provincial Grand Lodge of Antrimplaceholder image
John Edens, the Provincial Grand Master of the Provincial Grand Lodge of Antrim

John Edens, the Provincial Grand Master of the Provincial Grand Lodge of Antrim, said he was speaking out as part of plans to modernise and be more open - but he stopped short of sharing intimate details of their private rituals which he said must stay confidential.

Asked by Donna what actually happens at the initiation ceremony for new members, he told her, he could not tell her that.

Donna Traynor interviews John Edens, the Provincial Grand Master of the Provincial Grand Lodge of Antrimplaceholder image
Donna Traynor interviews John Edens, the Provincial Grand Master of the Provincial Grand Lodge of Antrim

He explained: "That's part of our secrets...but what I would like to say is that there is nothing untoward or sinister in any of our initiation sessions…there is nothing where the individual is put in danger at any stage.

"They are put at their ease before they come in. The beauty of it is that during the thing, anything that happens is totally explained to them, why we did this and what that means. So then after the initiation they know exactly what's happened and what they've done and what they've taken on."

In the latest episode of her “Donna Traynor Conversations” series which is available on her YouTube channel from today, Donna said that from researching on the internet public speculation on the initiation talked about "a noose around someone's neck, a blade on their chest, a rolled-up trouser leg, something about a goat. Now, it sounds strange to me. It sounds very ritualistic. Is any of that true?"

John replied: "I don't want to say it's not true, but I can safely say that we've never seen a goat - other than in a field somewhere!"

Freemason collarsplaceholder image
Freemason collars

The Provincial Grand Master said that "mysticism" around Freemasonry is part of the attraction of the organisation and is "enticing" for new members.

He added: "The one thing that I will say is there's no treasure. A lot of people are under the impression that we're running the world, and we have stacks of treasure hidden away somewhere in vaults. It's not true."

John also denied that favouritism exists among Freemasons in real world scenarios such as in business and employment.

He said: "I would be naive really to say that it has never happened and historically going back, people would maybe get promoted in various jobs and things like that because they were known Freemasons.

Donna Traynorplaceholder image
Donna Traynor

"But I have to say now, with the employment laws and various things, that doesn't exist at all in any shape or form... favouritism or anything like that just doesn't exist now."

But he confirmed Freemasons do have a secret handshake, even joking with Donna after taking her hand that he might have given her a masonic handshake without her knowing.

He said: "It's purely to recognise fellow Freemasons. Now, when I say that, it's not to exclude any of the other company, but it's just to let the man know that you're a Freemason in case he wants to say something about Freemasonry, which the other part of the company doesn't want to know, or shouldn't know, or it's not necessary to know."

Elsewhere in the wide-ranging sit-down, John said that religion is left at the door but all members must have a belief in a "Supreme Being", meaning that atheists would not be accepted.

He revealed: "It is non-political and non-religious. Something that is not allowed to be discussed in lodge rooms is politics or religion.

"You're known as an Irish Freemason. So the North and South doesn't really come into it. We would all be Freemasons in Ireland. The only thing that you need to be a Freemason is a belief in the Supreme Being, so you're getting all walks of life that can be a Freemason.

"The majority of Masons are in the north of Ireland. There's no denying that. However, their religion is of no significance. The fact that they're Protestants or Catholics or Sikhs or whatever it is, as long as they believe in the Supreme Being.

"Freemasonry is a completely separate organisation to the Orange Order and what we would call the Loyal Orders.

"Of course we would have members of the Orange Order, and we would have members of the Royal Black Preceptory as well but they have joined Freemasonry. It's not a continuance line between the Orange and the Black organisations to Freemasonry.

"Irrespective of what your belief is, any belief in a Supreme Being would be a God... for the peace, love, and harmony of a lodge. But if a man has no belief, how can he commit to a lodge if he has no belief to tie him to that lodge?

Some religious denominations such have the Catholic Church have forbidden membership. John said they have reached out to them in a bid to allay any concerns they might have.

He explained: "We have asked on numerous occasions to meet up and discuss this with various churches and organisations and they have refused.

"I understand fully that the Catholic Church had put out a papal bull at one stage that they couldn't be Freemasons. But my understanding is that that has been lifted, and we have Catholics as well, and Muslims, and Sikhs and various religions."

While stating they are diverse and inclusive as a fraternity and therefore a men-only organisation, John said he cannot see women being able to join in his lifetime.

He revealed: "I would say never say never, but at this moment in time I wouldn't see it happening. Now, not for any reason that we have anything against the ladies. Far, far from it.

"If it wasn't for our ladies in Freemasonry, our wives and partners and friends, it would be very, very difficult for Freemasonry to exist. That's my opinion on that, because they are very, very supportive.

"But I know from my own personal experience, Freemasonry is my thing. My wife wouldn't want to join Freemasonry. There are brethren there whose wives are lady Freemasons, and quite happy to do that. So, there is a facility for the ladies, but not in Irish Freemasonry with the men at the moment.

"It is a men's organisation. Ladies aren't members of the men's Freemasonry side of it, but they're not excluded from the social aspect, or the festive boards, the barbecues and the dinners and things. Now, I'm not saying that that didn't happen in previous years. You maybe got a ladies' night once a year, but now you have to be modernised, and the lodges are having barbecues, quizzes, nights, and families and friends are invited to that."

Other revelations in the interview include Donna asking if people are "blackballed" in the admission process, with John describing it as simply a vote in a ballot box and "a secret ballot to save embarrassment, either to the individual that is putting that vote forward or to the man himself".

He also spoke of how they raise vital funds for many local charities and how in the modern world they want to be more open and "have moved on from hiding away".

John added: "It is basically to quell some of the perceptions of Freemasonry, so that we are more open and involved with the community and bring the community in, that they can see that we're not the bad guys all the time.

"Any organisation would need new blood. Our age profile is high, I can't deny that. But we are getting there with the younger masons, and they are coming on board. Freemasonry is too good an organisation to die and that's why it will always keep going.

"In 10 years' time I would perceive it to be a very vibrant, modernised organisation. I can bring it forward in such a way that at this moment in time we have a group of young men which we could call Solomon's Builders. These are young men under the age of 45. "They are mentored by our Provincial Secretary and a Provincial Assistant Grand Master, and these men are very, very active socially, as well as masonically.

"Our secrets and our ritual cannot be touched. That's the most important thing. It will never change. Well, it should never change. You should never say never, but it will never change because if it's not broke, don't fix it and it is an excellent ritual."

*To watch the full "Behind Closed Doors" interview search Donna Traynor Conversations on YouTube

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice