No public inquiry on failures in screening
Stormont's health minister has ruled out a public inquiry into cervical screening failures at a Northern Ireland health trust following the publication of an expert review.
Mike Nesbitt endorsed the opinion of the review's author Professor Sir Frank Atherton, who concluded that a statutory public inquiry was unlikely to bring further clarity around screening failings within the Southern Health Trust.


Campaign group Ladies with Letters has criticised the announcement and has vowed to keeping pressing for an inquiry.
Around 17,500 women in the trust area who were screened between 2008 and 2021 had to have their results rechecked after concerns were first raised in a report commissioned by the Royal College of Pathologists.
A trust review showed eight women went on to develop cancer after their smears were misread.
Last year, Mr Nesbitt asked Sir Frank, the former chief medical officer in Wales, to review the various reports that had been published on the screening issues.
In his review, Sir Frank noted that “false negatives” were an “inherent” risk in all such screening programmes.
However, in regard to the programme run by the Southern Trust, he found there had been “clear management and governance failings” within both the trust and the Public Health Agency.
In respect of individual responsibility for screening failings, Sir Frank made clear that no-one had deliberately set out to cause harm or deliver a poor service.
But he added: “Any under-performance by the screeners within the SHSCT should have been properly identified and corrected.
“That this did not happen is a recurrent theme in the documents I have reviewed and in the discussions with programme managers and leaders. Some sanctions are already in place; I understand that individual screeners who are deemed to have under-performed have been removed from the programme and either left the NHS service or been reassigned to other duties.
“However, within the context of a screening programme I believe that it would be inappropriate to seek further sanction against individual screeners.”
Sir Frank noted that significant improvements had been made to the current cervical screening services in Northern Ireland, including a move from testing based on cervical cytology to primary HPV tests.
He said the reconfiguration of laboratory services into a centralised Belfast operation had also improved oversight.
On the issue of a public inquiry, Sir Frank acknowledged he had been given a “very clear message” from women affected by the failings that they wanted the issues examined by a public inquiry.
He said he also heard the case, put mainly by officials, that a public inquiry would be “time consuming, risk retraumatisation, further delay resolution, involve significant expense, and potentially fail to deliver any greater clarity on the nature and extent of programme failures which are documented in the commissioned reports and summarised here”.
Responding to the review's publication, Mr Nesbitt said he acknowledged it had been a “particularly difficult and challenging time for the women and their families who have been impacted by cervical cancer".
“I want to pay tribute to their determination and acknowledge the profound effect these events have had on their lives,” he said.
Dr Stephen Austin, the Southern Trust's medical director, said: “We apologise again to the women and families affected for past shortcomings in our cervical screening services and for the anxiety and distress this has caused.
“This report identifies clear failings in management, governance and quality assurance within the trust. We fully accept that those failings should not have happened.”