Brandon Lewis criticises Conor Murphy over ‘untenable’ claims about victims’ payment funding

Brandon Lewis has dismissed as “untenable” claims from Stormont’s Finance Minister that he does not have the money to fund a victims’ payment scheme

Northern Ireland Secretary of State, Brandon Lewis.
Northern Ireland Secretary of State, Brandon Lewis.

The Secretary of State said Conor Murphy’s assertion that Executive coffers will not stretch to cover the costs of the scheme is not credible.

Mr Lewis, who said the first year of the scheme could cost under £29 million, highlighted that the Executive had an underspend of millions in the current financial year.

His remarks come amid an ongoing stand-off between the Northern Ireland Office and Stormont Executive over who will foot a potential £1.2 billion total bill for the delayed payments for those injured during the Troubles.

Earlier this month, the Court of Appeal in Belfast ruled that Stormont was under a legal duty to fund the payment scheme for injured victims of the conflict.

It made no finding on the source of that funding and gave the Executive and Northern Ireland Office four weeks to find an agreed solution.

During the ongoing impasse, Mr Lewis has singled out Mr Murphy and his Sinn Fein party for criticism.

On Wednesday, the Northern Ireland Secretary again criticised the Stormont minister.

He told BBC Radio Ulster: “With a £15 billion (Treasury) block grant from the year where they’ve had an underspend, that they can’t find the few million pound they need to find for what is a priority, what’s been a legal commitment, what has been there since 2014, for the Sinn Fein Department of Finance minister to continue to delay this is untenable.

“How can he stand there and say with any kind of credibility that from a £15 billion block grant approximately, that he is not prepared to make decisions to allocate a few million pounds to the victims’ payment scheme that they are committed to since 2014?”

His comments came after he on Tuesday met with Mr Murphy, First Minister Arlene Foster, deputy First Minister Michelle O’Neill and Justice Minister Naomi Long to discuss the funding dispute.

The Conservative MP said the situation emphasised the need for the Finance Minister to press ahead with setting up a delayed independent spending oversight body.

Stormont parties committed to establishing a Fiscal Council in the New Decade, New Approach deal to restore powersharing.

The independent body, which was supposed to be set up by July last year, was designed to conduct an annual assessment of the Executive’s plans to balance its budget.

It would also examine the ongoing sustainability of departmental finances and assess the effectiveness of long-term efficiency measures.

Mr Lewis said such a council could provide “transparency” on Mr Murphy’s claims that there are not sufficient funds to pay for the victims’ scheme.

But Mr Murphy disputed Mr Lewis’s position, and also said the first year estimate is as high as £145 million.

Accusing Mr Lewis of “dithering and delay”, Mr Murphy said the UK Government should pay for the scheme because it legislated for it as Westminster

“The Victims Payment Scheme was designed at Westminster and policy decisions were taken there,” Mr Murphy said. “Funding for it also needs to come from there.

“The Executive’s budgets are already stretched and the pension could amount to costs of up to £1.2 billion.

“Therefore it is disappointing that Mr Lewis continues to claim that the pension will cost £28 million in the first year when he knows that the Government Actuary’s Department has estimated the cost at between £70 million and £145 million in the first year.

“It is time the British Government acted to pay for the scheme it created so that victims should not have to face any further delays.”

Mrs Foster, meanwhile, has made clear that victims will get their payments, regardless of who ultimately funds them.

She told BBC Radio Ulster on Wednesday: “It’s important to say to people this morning, regardless of where the money comes from, whether it comes from the Executive or from the British Government, that the Executive will be paying the money when it falls due because that is our legal duty and it’s very important to say that.”

The Executive has recently received costing predictions from the Government’s Actuary Department based on numbers provided by the Executive Office.

Those range from £600 million to £1.2 billion for the lifetime of the scheme, with a central estimate of £848 million.

The scheme should have been open for applications at the end of May last year.

It was first delayed when Sinn Fein refused to designate a Stormont department to administer it, after objecting to Government eligibility criteria that excluded former paramilitaries convicted of causing serious harm.

Ms O’Neill eventually agreed to nominate a department last August following a highly critical court judgment that found she had been acting unlawfully.

However, the separate stand-off involving the Government and the wider Stormont Executive over funding remains unresolved.


A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this story on our website. While I have your attention, I also have an important request to make of you.

With the coronavirus lockdown having a major impact on many of our advertisers — and consequently the revenue we receive — we are more reliant than ever on you taking out a digital subscription.

Subscribe to and enjoy unlimited access to the best Northern Ireland and UK news and information online and on our app. With a digital subscription, you can read more than 5 articles, see fewer ads, enjoy faster load times, and get access to exclusive newsletters and content. Visit now to sign up.

Our journalism costs money and we rely on advertising, print and digital revenues to help to support them. By supporting us, we are able to support you in providing trusted, fact-checked content for this website.

Alistair Bushe