Call for Prime Minister to launch investigation into 'role and conduct' of NIO during Brexit after Boris aide claims
The Prime Minister has been urged to establish an investigation into the role of the Northern Ireland Office (NIO) during Brexit negotiations, after a claim by Boris Johnson’s former adviser that it was “on the side of” Ireland and Sinn Fein.
Jim Allister says the comments by Dominic Cummings are of “profound constitutional seriousness” – and he has written to Sir Keir Starmer demanding a “wholly independent investigation into the role and conduct” of the government department.


The TUV leader said it is “deeply troubling” that the NIO “had to be excluded from significant parts of the most important constitutional negotiations in modern British history because it was regarded as hostile to those objectives”.
The DUP deputy leader Michelle McIlveen says that if Mr Cummings’ account is even partially accurate, “it raises profoundly serious questions about the culture and mindset” within the NIO.
However, the NIO has dismissed the comments, calling them “nonsense” and saying they work on behalf of everyone in Northern Ireland.
Mr Cummings – chief advisor to Boris Johnson during negotiations with the EU about the terms of the UK’s withdrawal – said that ministers were not in control of large sections of the UK civil service, citing parts of the Cabinet Office and NIO.
He said the Tory government had to “cut out large parts of” the NIO, “because they were on the side of the Irish government and Sinn Fein IRA, not the British government”.
Mr Allister has now written to the Prime Minister about the claims, urging him to establish “a wholly independent investigation into the role and conduct of the Northern Ireland Office during the Brexit negotiations”.
The North Antrim MP told the News Letter that the remarks “amount to an allegation of profound constitutional seriousness: that the Northern Ireland Office was so institutionally captured that it was effectively aligned with the Irish Government and Sinn Fein/IRA rather than advancing the objectives of the United Kingdom Government.
“These are not allegations that can be examined through an internal Whitehall review or a process run by No.10, the Cabinet Office or the NIO itself. Any such exercise would lack credibility and would rightly be dismissed as the Government marking its own homework.
“If these claims are to be examined at all, there must be a wholly independent investigation, led by a senior King’s Counsel or a retired senior judge of established standing, with no prior involvement in the Brexit negotiations or in Northern Ireland governance”.
Mr Allister added: “A UK Government department, funded by the British taxpayer, staffed by UK civil servants, and headed by a UK Cabinet minister, exists to serve the interests and objectives of the United Kingdom Government.
“The suggestion that such a department had to be excluded from significant parts of the most important constitutional negotiations in modern British history because it was regarded as hostile to those objectives is deeply troubling.
“These matters go to the heart of trust in government and the integrity of the Union. They deserve a genuinely independent investigation to establish the truth.”
Michelle McIlveen said the role of the NIO “is not to act as a passive facilitator for Dublin’s objectives or to defer to nationalist pressure”.
The DUP deputy leader told the News Letter: “Its duty is to uphold the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom and to represent British interests without embarrassment or apology when it comes to Northern Ireland.
“Instead, what unionists have witnessed repeatedly is a department more concerned with Dublin’s interests than London’s interests. That weakness paved the way for arrangements that no unionist ever consented to and that ran a coach and horses through the cross community consent mechanisms of the Belfast and successor agreements.
“The NIO must start from the principle that our place in the UK is not negotiable and must be defended robustly at every level.”
Asked about Mr Cummings’s comments, an NIO spokesperson said: “We categorically reject these claims. They are nonsense and do not reflect the NIO's steadfast work on behalf of all the people and communities of Northern Ireland”.
Dominic Cummings made the comments on The Spectator’s Quite Right podcast, with the former Tory minister Michael Gove. He also criticised the role of parts of the Cabinet Office.
“Remember, they leaked against their own government during the Brexit negotiations… which the Cabinet Secretary apologised for and said was unprecedented in British history to have our own government lawyers leaking against our own government’s negotiating team”, he said.
Mr Cummings described sections of the civil service as “massively pro remain” – and said the European Convention on Human Rights was “a religious principle” for them.