Chief Constable contradicts Sinn Fein claim that warning charity over paedophile concerns would 'prejudice' investigation
PSNI boss Jon Boutcher says police have an obligation to notify organisations over individuals being investigated for child sex offences – and that doing so would not prejudice any police investigation.
The Chief Constable’s comments to the Policing Board contradict a claim by Sinn Fein minister Conor Murphy that the party could not do anything which could “potentially be prejudicial” to the police investigation.


The DUP has welcomed the comments as “dispelling” Sinn Féin’s Conor Murphy’s claims that warning the British Heart Foundation could have prejudiced the investigation – and called for an apology.
South Antrim MLA Trevor Clarke, who sits on the board, said: “It is important that, on issues as serious as safeguarding children, public representatives are factual in the comments they make.
“I welcome the Chief Constable’s clarification. Conor Murphy’s extraordinary claims about prejudicing the PSNI investigation now lie in tatters. Conor Murphy should now apologise and make it clear that he accepts what he said was wrong.”
Responding to a question from Mr Clarke, the police boss had said during the meeting “why would that prejudice the investigation? It wouldn’t”.
There is growing scrutiny around how Sinn Fein secretly handled the fact that one of its press officers, Michael McMonagle, was under investigation by police for child sex offences.
Two other press officers – Sean Mag Uidhir and Caolan McGinley – resigned on Saturday, days after it emerged they had given references McMonagle when he was applying for a job at the British Heart Foundation (BHF).
The party did not alert the charity to the fact Mr McMonagle had been suspended – or indeed the reason for his suspension.
Economy Minister Conor Murphy suggested on Tuesday that the party had no other option than to remain silent on the issue, so as not to interfere with a police investigation.
“When we suspended him and he ended his engagement with us, that matter then, until the point that he was charged, is a matter for the police,” Mr Murphy said.
“We have no involvement, it is not our job to do the investigation. To do anything in relation to that could potentially be prejudicial. It is up to the police to gather sufficient evidence to decide to charge him.”
DUP MLA Trevor Clarke questioned Jon Boutcher at the Northern Ireland Policing Board on Thursday – asking if Sinn Fein sharing the information with any other employer could prejudice police investigations.
Responding, Mr Boutcher said he did not know much about the case, but added: “If indeed we did reach out to Sinn Fein to give information that concerned us about an individual that we felt they should know about, that wouldn’t prejudice an investigation”.
Mr Boutcher added: “We can’t track organisations who are receiving information about individuals who might be working for them. If people write to us, then we’ll respond to those people if there is a concern about an individual. If the question is, would that prejudice the investigation, the answer is, and I don’t know the detail, I don’t see how it would prejudice an investigation.”
He said the PSNI could provide a written response about what the National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC) policy, and the PSNI policy, is – adding “but of course, why would that prejudice the investigation? It wouldn’t. Is that helpful?”.