DAERA must answer outstanding questions over Fivemiletown at Committee, says DUP deputy leader ahead of Monday's meeting
DUP deputy leader Michelle McIlveen has said the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) must provide answers over the controversial Fivemiletown cattle case at Monday’s Assembly evidence session.
The Agriculture Committee member made the comments ahead of Monday’s evidence session, which she says must provide a “critical opportunity” for DAERA to explain its actions amid mounting concern within the farming community.


The case has attracted widespread attention following the recent shooting of cattle at a farm in Fivemiletown, with questions being raised about the circumstances surrounding the Department's intervention and the decisions taken by officials and veterinary personnel.
In total, 51 cattle were slaughtered by Department of Agriculture (DAERA) staff in June.
The manner in which the animals were killed, by being shot in an open field, has been the focus of much of the criticism that has been levelled at DAERA officials – but Agricultural Minister Andrew Muir said last week that alternative arrangements were not possible in this case.
Minister Muir said this was “due to the lack of suitable, safe facilities on farm to gather up and contain animals to protect both the animals and staff; the temperament of the animals; the additional stress of handling and suitability of the animals for transport e.g. some of the cattle were horned; and the reality that it was simply not possible to transport all of the animals away from the location”.
However, Ms McIlveen said the issue had now gone well beyond one farm and had raised fundamental questions about the way DAERA exercises its powers.
“Monday Committee session is not simply another departmental briefing,” she added. “It is a critical opportunity for DAERA to account for its actions in a case which has shaken confidence across Northern Ireland's farming community.
“This issue has gone far beyond a single farm. It has raised fundamental questions about decision-making within the Department, the role of senior officials, veterinary oversight, and whether the powers entrusted to DAERA have been exercised appropriately and proportionately.
“The entire agriculture sector will be watching Monday’s evidence session closely. Farmers will be listening to what the Minister and his officials say. Above all, they will be looking to see whether difficult questions are answered honestly and transparently.
“DAERA's credibility as the regulator responsible for enforcing animal welfare legislation is on the line. Public confidence cannot be restored through partial disclosures or carefully managed statements. It will only be restored through full transparency and accountability.”
Providing an update to MLAs last week, Mr Muir ordered an external review of the circumstances.
But Ms McIlveen has called for those involved in key decisions to be held accountable and to explain how and why those decisions were reached.
She added: "While an independent review is welcome, this cannot become simply another 'lessons learned' exercise. Where mistakes have been made, there must be accountability. Those responsible for decisions must be prepared to explain and justify them.
“That is precisely why I have referred this matter to the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons. Questions surrounding the professional conduct and veterinary decision-making involved deserve independent scrutiny alongside the Department's own review.
“Monday's Committee meeting must mark the beginning of a process that establishes the full facts. Farmers deserve answers. Confidence in DAERA will only begin to recover when every outstanding question has been addressed openly and fully.”
Meanwhile, the Ulster Farmers’ Union has called for an independent expert panel to be established to support and review the investigation into DAERA’s enforcement operation.
UFU President John McLenaghan said: “The farming community will not regain confidence if the Department is perceived to be investigating itself.
"This review must be demonstrably independent, transparent and robust.”
