Daera vet says best way to euthanise cattle was 'with their comrades' - as she explains 'devastating' impact on staff
A senior vet in the department of agriculture (Daera) says officials had worked for years to try and get animals off the farm where they were eventually culled.
The Daera employee also defended the manner of the cull, after uproar from politicians and farmers over the shooting of the animals in an open field.


Elsie McGarvey, senior principal veterinary officer at Daera, said research shows that for cattle in semi-feral states, “the best way to euthanise them is in their environment with their comrades”.
The senior vet was giving evidence to MLAs on Stormont’s Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (Aera) committee on Monday, alongside the minister Andrew Muir.
The emergency meeting had been called amid growing disquiet in recent weeks over the cull outside Fivemiletown, County Tyrone, in June.
Ms McGarvey was being questioned by Sinn Féin MLA Declan McAleer, who asked why equipment could not have been brought onto the site to deal with the issue differently.
The Daera vet said staff had previously tried to use a mobile crush and gates, and there was a “near miss” with a member of staff.
“There are a number of people who worked on this case for years and have tried everything to get this man to divest himself of cattle, over a number of years, and he was not able to do it”, she said.
The senior vet said there are peer reviewed reports “that talk about cattle in semi-feral states, and the best way to euthanise them. And the best way to euthanise them is in their environment with their comrades, and that is published…. and anybody that wants to look up the EFSA report on that will see it”.
Elsie McGarvey also spoke of the impact the events had had on staff.
She said one Daera employee, who had been working to get animals off the farm for years, was “absolutely devastated”. The Daera vet added that the department “had to have a debrief because staff were so upset”.
Minister Muir said that Ms McGarvey and deputy chief veterinary officer Gemma Daly – who also gave evidence – were the two professional veterinary officials in Daera who were “closest to the events”.