Economy minister criticised over differing attitudes to China and Israel as she jets off on Beijing investment mission

Stormont’s economy ministry has been accused of “losing its moral compass” over Caoimhe Archibald’s trip to China to boost Northern Ireland’s economic links with the communist superpower, despite banning her officials from engaging in UK trade talks with Israel.

The Sinn Fein minister said she was seeking a “balance” between “economic opportunity” and “upholding our responsibilities and values” when it comes to trading with China. She is currently on a five day trip to the country – having said she would use the trip to raise “issues of concern”.

Economy minister Dr Caoimhe Archibald is currently on a five day investment trip to China. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wireplaceholder image
Economy minister Dr Caoimhe Archibald is currently on a five day investment trip to China. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wire

But unionists have criticised the Sinn Fein minister over her differing attitudes to China and Israel – with the Ulster Unionists saying her “enthusiasm” for trade should “apply across the board”.

The TUV leader criticised the economy department for not standing with Israel, but being “perfectly willing to stand beside Beijing”.

In November, minister Archibald issued an instruction to state-backed trade body Invest NI to draw up plans to “eliminate any risk of public funds being used to support the manufacture of arms or components that are used for genocide”.

She also said her economy department would not engage in the UK government's trade talks with Israel “while it continues to illegally occupy and impose apartheid on Palestine”.

That decision was challenged by the DUP, who brought the decision before the Executive. However, Alliance ministers sided with Sinn Fein on the issue.

North Antrim MP Jim Allister told the News Letter that Israel is never afforded the kind of consideration the minister has shown China. He highlighted a China–Northern Ireland Economic, Trade and Investment Cooperation Forum held last month “under the authority” of the economy department.

The TUV leader told the News Letter: “This was the very same Department that, only weeks ago, informed us — with the greatest moral gravity — that it could not support businesses with links to Israel. Yet, astonishingly, that same Department rolled out the red carpet at a five-star hotel for representatives of the People’s Republic of China: a regime which MI6, the National Security Adviser and the Intelligence and Security Committee all describe as a ‘systemic challenge’ and a threat to the United Kingdom.

“A country ranked 15th on the Open Doors World Watch List for persecution of Christians — where churches are bulldozed and pastors are imprisoned.

“So the Minister for the Economy can summon moral outrage when it comes to a democratic ally — the world’s only Jewish state — but apparently none when dealing with a communist dictatorship that silences faith, crushes dissent, and spies on its own people.

“It will not stand with Israel, but it is perfectly willing to stand beside Beijing.

“And this is no minor trade sideshow. According to the Chinese Consul-General, the forum which met in Belfast was the culmination of years of deepening engagement — including a £34 million ten-year educational cooperation agreement, senior trade missions, and direct links between Chinese state institutions and our schools, colleges and businesses.

“The signal could not be clearer: the Economy Minister herself was the keynote speaker — underscoring the extent of Sinn Fein’s political comfort with a regime condemned by the UN and others for mass internment, forced labour and the cultural destruction of the Uyghur people — abuses many international observers have described as genocide.

“This is infiltration dressed up as investment. And the Department for the Economy is giving it a platform, a microphone, and taxpayer money.

“When a Department prefers the handshake of Beijing to the friendship of Jerusalem, it hasn’t merely lost its way – it has lost its moral compass.”

Ulster Unionist economy spokesperson Diana Armstrong said Northern Ireland “must seize every opportunity to grow our economy” – but that the minister has had “limited engagement” with the United States – a market which she said “has been a longstanding ally and offers enormous potential, particularly in sectors such as defence and aerospace”.

“If enthusiasm for trade is genuine, it should apply across the board, not just when it suits a particular narrative. Our economy needs a strategy that champions opportunity wherever it exists, while standing firmly by our principles”, Mrs Armstrong said.

Since the return of the Stormont Executive, there have been questions about meetings between a number of local ministers and Chinese government officials. Finance minister John O’Dowd met China’s consul general in Belfast – and last summer, the Executive Office faced criticism from human rights campaigners after refusing to release information requested by the BBC about a meeting between Chinese officials and the first and deputy first ministers – arguing it could harm “international relations”. Stormont has no remit over international relations.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice