Farming minister Andrew Muir survives no confidence motion - as Alliance MLAs accused of 'stunt' as they walk out of the Assembly
Stormont’s farming minister has survived a no confidence vote in the Assembly over his handling of events surrounding a controversial cattle cull near Fivemiletown – with Alliance MLAs staging a walkout in protest at the DUP motion.
Andrew Muir’s party secured support from Sinn Féin, but faced opposition from all the Assembly’s unionist parties over how he has handled the fallout from the June incident.


51 cattle were culled by Mr Muir’s Daera department, following a court order which disqualified the herd owner from keeping animals.
Local politicians, members of the public and farmers raised concerns about the public nature of the incident and questions have been posed about whether all options were exhausted before the cows were shot. A review commissioned by the department is now underway.
During the Assembly debate on Tuesday, DUP MLA for the area Deborah Erskine said it gave her “no great pleasure” to move a motion of no confidence in a minister, “not least a minister who is supposed to represent our farming community”.
That prompted smirks of derision from Minister Muir and his party’s deputy leader Eóin Tennyson across the chamber. However, Ms Erskine continued to accuse the Alliance minister of being “more concerned with penalising the farmer than promoting them, more concerned with finding fault on the farm than finding answers in his own department”.
The Fermanagh and South Tyrone MLA said: “Let's be absolutely clear what this debate is about and what it is not. This is not a debate about whether a court order should be obeyed. Of course, it should.
“This is not a debate about whether animal welfare offences should not be taken seriously. Of course, they should. And this is not a debate about whether Daera staff should be subjected to abuse or intimidation, they should not.
“This is a debate about judgment, leadership, transparency, and ministerial accountability, and it is about the minister's response when the public began asking very serious questions”, she said.
“And whilst the news cycle has moved on, it hasn't for my community. This issue is still discussed, and it is felt as rawly as that summer's day in June. It isn't me or the DUP saying that we have lost confidence in the agriculture minister. Indeed, Daera and the minister has received numerous, multiple no confidence motions brought to his door”, the DUP MLA said.
Alliance minister Naomi Long slammed the DUP for bringing the motion to the Assembly during the Drumcree issue, and said it was about “castigating another minister for doing their job”.
Pointing out that a review into the matter had yet to conclude, she accused the DUP of trying to turn the Assembly into a “kangaroo court”.
“No similar motions were brought when other court orders were implemented, when other culls were undertaken – whether that was under Michelle O’Neill or Michelle McIlveen”, Mrs Long added.
The Alliance boss said the motion was really about the DUP being opposed to Minister Muir’s approach to climate change.
“This is a political stunt, Mr Speaker, to distract people from the internal difficulties of those to my right. A DUP mired in scandal and sleaze, and led by the nose by Jamie Bryson”, she said.
She accused her rivals of pantomime politics and said her MLAs would leave to focus on other work, before the entire Alliance team walked out of the chamber.
Opposition leader Matthew O’Toole described the walkout as a “stunt” – saying it wouldn’t help for those in the public who “view the pantomime here with contempt”.
UUP boss Jon Burrows accused the Alliance Party of being arrogant and tone deaf over the Fivemiletown cattle cull.
“Whether you agree with this motion or not, the Alliance Party and their minister didn’t even have the decency to listen to the representatives of farmers across this country who feel unsupported, overregulated, not listened to”, the North Antrim MLA said.
Sinn Fein MLA Aine Murphy said the issues raised go far beyond the events of the day. She questioned why Daera took the course of action it did, asked whether it had followed its own policies and queried whether “intervention could have happened sooner”.
“Farmers must be able to trust that when difficult situations arise, the department will act fairly, proportionately, and with respect for everyone involved”, she said.
The Fermanagh and South Tyrone MLA said that when a Daera-commissioned review is complete, the public will “expect a clear explanation of what happened”.
“I understand the strength of feeling behind this motion. The minister now faces a significant task in restoring public confidence”, she said, adding that the communities around Fivemiletown deserve, clarity, accountability and transparency.
32 MLAs voted for the no confidence motion, with 38 voting against.