Fivemiletown cattle cull: Muir slams 'highly irresponsible and very misleading' commentary - and threats to DAERA staff
Stormont’s farming minister has set out his response to the growing controversy over the culling of 51 cattle in an open field – and slammed the “highly irresponsible and very misleading” commentary about civil servants following the incident.
The incident took place on a farm near Fivemiletown in June, after a court issued a disposal order against a farmer who had been disqualified for life from keeping, owning or participating in the keeping of animals.


However, the row over the incident escalated in recent days amid social media backlash and growing calls from minister Andrew Muir’s political rivals for transparency from the agriculture department (Daera).
Yesterday afternoon, Mr Muir issued a statement to the Northern Ireland Assembly on the matter, saying it was to ensure that “any public commentary is grounded in accurate information”.
The statement said that under the Welfare of Animals Act (NI) 2011, if a person is convicted of certain offences, including causing unnecessary suffering to animals, a court may make an order depriving them of ownership of the animal and for its disposal, including by destruction – something the department “must comply with”.
Daera pointed out that on June 8, the farmer in question was convicted of 21 offences – including six of causing unnecessary suffering to an animal. Given the “particular circumstances that applied”, officials had given the individual “an extended period of three weeks to sell or dispose of the animals”.
However, the minister said that the keeper had “only divested himself of a small number of animals” and the department was therefore “obliged to comply with the Deprivation Order in relation to any remaining stock in the keeper’s possession”.
“I am advised that after careful consideration of all available options, the department was unfortunately left with no reasonable alternative to comply with the court order, other than to euthanise the animals,” Mr Muir said.
The manner of their killing, being shot in an open field, has been the focus of much of the criticism that has been levelled at Daera officials – but the minister said alternative arrangements were not possible in this case.
The Alliance MLA said this was “due to the lack of suitable, safe facilities on farm to gather up and contain animals to protect both the animals and staff; the temperament of the animals; the additional stress of handling and suitability of the animals for transport e.g. some of the cattle were horned; and the reality that it was simply not possible to transport all of the animals away from the location”.
Mr Muir said: “I have been alarmed by some of the highly inaccurate and irresponsible commentary surrounding the team’s actions. Officials have outlined that no animal was chased around fields by Daera staff, no animal was shot multiple times, nor were there sounds of loud gunfire. It is standard practice that silencers are used, an important detail both from an animal welfare and from a public concern perspective.
“In such cases where a Deprivation Order is granted it is the legal responsibility of the disqualified keeper to dispose of any animals euthanised. In this case, and as the keeper also had convictions for failure to dispose of animal byproducts (which was in relation to diseased animals), the department made the decision to arrange collection and disposal of the animals at the department’s expense.”
He added: “The conduct of the operation was dynamically assessed by the team on site, including consideration of public visibility.
“Operations were conducted in the most suitable areas available within the fields to minimise exposure to public view and to maximise operational safety.
“Although complete screening from all possible vantage points could not be guaranteed, efforts were made to keep the operation out of public view.”
On commentary about the actions of Daera staff, the minister said: “Some of it has been highly irresponsible and very misleading. Other commentary, particularly on social media, has had the effect of encouraging and provoking quite disgraceful and unacceptable reactions, including some that are abusive and clearly misogynistic.
“That commentary has led to threats being made against some Daera staff and multiple other staff being subjected to significant abuse online, in person and through written correspondence.
“That is not acceptable in any scenario, and certainly not when it comes to our civil and public servants carrying out their lawful duties.”
The DUP says that while the Daera minister's written statement to the Assembly provides additional information about the events in Fivemiletown, it is “clear that significant questions remain”.
The party’s Fermanagh and South Tyrone representative Deborah Erskine has criticised the Alliance minister for the way information about the incident has been relayed to the public in recent weeks.
Reacting to the minister’s statement on Thursday afternoon, the DUP MLA said: “This information should not have come through a drip feed of statements and media reports over the past number of weeks.
“Given the level of public concern, the Minister should have been far more forthcoming from the outset.
“I wrote to the Minister on both 30 June and again on 17 July seeking clarity on a range of issues surrounding this operation. While today's statement answers some questions, it also raises further ones.
“In particular, there remains a need for greater transparency around the options considered before the decision was taken to euthanise the remaining animals. We also need the precise legal basis for those decisions and the operational planning surrounding the exercise.
“The announcement of an independent external review was welcome but it is essential that it is genuinely independent. It must examine all aspects of the operation without fear or favour.
“The public’s version of events must also play a role in getting to the bottom of what actually took place in the run up to the 29th June and subsequently.
“The statement fails again today to apologise to constituents that witnessed this incident occur and are genuinely concerned by what happened in a quiet rural area. That should be at the very least something that could and should be offered at this stage.
“Everyone agrees that animal welfare legislation must be enforced and that abuse of public servants is completely unacceptable. However, those facts cannot prevent legitimate scrutiny of decisions taken by a government department. The public deserve clear answers. I will continue to press the Minister until those answers are provided”.