'Fundamental breakdown of trust between minister and farmers he's supposed to represent': Pressure mounts on embattled Andrew Muir

Pressure continued to mount on embattled Daera minister Andrew Muir over the weekend, as calls for him to quit echoed around the province.

The DUP, UUP and TUV are now united in calling for his head – as is the MP representing Mr Muir’s own constituency, independent unionist Alex Easton.

Andrew Muir is facing calls to resign over a cattle cull in Fivemiletown. Photo: Colm Lenaghan/Pacemakerplaceholder image
Andrew Muir is facing calls to resign over a cattle cull in Fivemiletown. Photo: Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker

The political demands for the minister to leave his post followed a vote of no confidence in him by the Ulster Farmers’ Union (UFU), as a row over a controversial cull of cattle in Fivemiletown deepened.

In the immediate aftermath of the UFU vote, the DUP pointed to its own no-confidence move to be filed when Stormont returns in two weeks, though on Friday its politicians stopped short of explicitly calling for Mr Muir to go in as many words.

Farmers gathered outside Stormont last Monday to protest the shooting of 51 cattle in Fivemiletown. Photo: Jonathan Porter/PressEyeplaceholder image
Farmers gathered outside Stormont last Monday to protest the shooting of 51 cattle in Fivemiletown. Photo: Jonathan Porter/PressEye

Last Monday, party MP Carla Lockhart led a protest of farmers outside Stormont in chants calling for the minister’s resignation; over the weekend, she reinforced that point.

The days since the protest have made it clear Mr Muir has “lost the confidence of the farming community he is supposed to represent”, the Upper Bann politician said, adding that “other voices have followed” the DUP in making calls for the minister to step down.

“This is no longer simply about criticism of an individual decision,” she told the News Letter. “There is a fundamental breakdown of trust between the minister, his department and the farming community.

“When our motion is tabled, every MLA and every party in Stormont will have the opportunity to sign it and demonstrate where they stand. It is simply not sustainable for an Agriculture Minister, who should be an advocate for our farmers, to continue when those farmers have lost confidence in his leadership.

Carla Lockhart MP has called for a multidisciplinary panel to review the cattle cull.placeholder image
Carla Lockhart MP has called for a multidisciplinary panel to review the cattle cull.

“There is also a wider issue of confidence in Daera. The department has significant responsibilities for regulating and enforcing animal welfare standards. Farmers must have confidence that those responsibilities are being exercised fairly and competently.”

The actions of Daera officials who carried out the cull are to be probed, but that investigation has been criticised by the UFU and politicians as the department itself is setting its terms and powers.

Ms Lockhart echoed those concerns, stating: “It’s clear that an investigatory panel with expertise beyond the veterinary world would command much more confidence.

“The minister cannot simply ignore the scale of concern around his leadership. Andrew Muir needs to give serious consideration to his position, and when the Assembly returns every MLA will have to decide whether they still have confidence in him.”

Alex Easton MP represents North Down in Westminster, the same area Andrew Muir represents in Stormont. Mr Easton is also calling on the Daera minister to quit.placeholder image
Alex Easton MP represents North Down in Westminster, the same area Andrew Muir represents in Stormont. Mr Easton is also calling on the Daera minister to quit.

Mr Muir has pledged not to resign, and over the weekend gave off an air of being unconcerned by the calls for him to go. On Saturday, for example, he posted on social media images of himself joining a parkrun in his North Down constituency, which is something of a hobby for the minister.

His own area’s MP has joined those demanding he quit, however, Alex Easton stating he “stands squarely behind” farmers, who he described as “the backbone of our rural economy and our food supply”.

“When an organisation representing farmers across Northern Ireland reaches the point of publicly calling for resignations, that cannot simply be brushed aside,” he said, adding that “famers and the wider public deserve clear answers” about the Fivemiletown cull.

"But the concerns raised by the UFU go beyond this one incident,” he said. “There is now a much wider breakdown in trust between many farmers and the department responsible for agriculture.

“In my view, Andrew Muir and his senior team have lost that confidence and are out of their depth in dealing with the serious challenges facing Northern Ireland agriculture.

“Leadership means taking responsibility when confidence has been lost. It cannot simply mean carrying on regardless while relations with the farming community deteriorate further.

“Our farmers deserve leadership that listens to them, understands their industry, treats them with respect and is accountable when things go wrong. For the good of our farming industry and to begin the process of rebuilding confidence, I am calling on Andrew Muir and the senior members of his team who have lost the confidence of the farming community to stand down immediately.”

The cull of 51 cattle took place in a field near Fivemiletown in June, after a court issued a disposal order against a farmer who had been disqualified for life from keeping, owning or participating in the keeping of animals.

However, critics have questioned whether the cull was necessary – as well as the manner in which it was carried out, as politicians complained people in the area could hear gunshots during the incident.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice