'Muir must go' - Farmers gather outside Stormont calling for Daera minister to quit over cattle cull

Protestors outside Stormont have called for the farming minister to go, as Andrew Muir faced questions inside over the growing controversy over a cattle cull carried out by his department in June.

A crowd of farmers and tractors assembled in front of parliament buildings as MLAs quizzed the minister over the actions of officials from his department of agriculture (Daera).

Protestors gather at the steps of Stormont over a cull of 51 cattle on a County Tyrone farm in June.placeholder image
Protestors gather at the steps of Stormont over a cull of 51 cattle on a County Tyrone farm in June.

In an emergency meeting of a Stormont committee, the Alliance minister and senior officials expressed their upset over the incident – but also robustly defended the decisions taken on the day.

While calls were heard outside for the minister’s resignation, MLAs made no such calls – with the DUP deputy leader saying the buck stops with officials.

The protest outside appears to have been largely organised via social media. Senior figures from the Ulster Farmer’s Union remained inside the building – having said their role was to “support” MLAs in seeking answers from the minister.

The minister said he appreciated “genuine and legitimate” concerns expressed by members of the public over the operation to cull the cows.

Mr Muir warned about the “very real impact of some of the misleading and inaccurate reporting and commentary” around the case.

“The wave of misogynistic, sectarian and homophobic hate, threats and intimidation against both officials and myself is despicable and deeply concerning”, he told MLAs on the agriculture committee.

The Daera minister said that he had received a death threat over the matter. “The fact that I have had to discuss this with the police and also officials are having to consider security measures and personal safety is unacceptable and seriously troubling.

“The misogynistic, sectarian and homophobic abuse does not reflect the majority of farmers who are respectful and kind”, he said.

DUP deputy leader Michelle McIlveen said that as a consequence of the operation, Daera “has lost all credibility in the eyes of the public where animal welfare is concerned”.

She said there is anger “right across the farming community, and the anger is coming from decent, hardworking farmers who are just trying to make a living from the land”.

“What happened appears to be brutal, appears to be inhumane, and ironically, what was meant to be an animal welfare intervention has become an animal welfare scandal at the hands of the department, and that’s totally regrettable”, the Strangford MLA said.

The minister said it was a “sensitive and a deeply distressing case” and said concerns would be examined in the independent review he announced last week.

“I think we all have a role in political life for leadership, in facts and understanding that we need to give time and space for the review to do its work, and for that review to be full and thorough, and for them to then fully examine the findings and recommendations arising from this”, the minister said.

A suggestion by Ms McIlveen that the public may viewed the cull as a “shoot-to-kill approach” by Daera prompted Mr Muir to ask for calm and for “people to temper their language around this, because I’ve received threats and that someone wants me shot”.

““So, we just need to lower the tone in this. We have a responsibility in our language”, the MLA said.

In a statement afterwards, Michelle McIlveen said the buck stopped with senior officials in Daera.

The DUP MLA said: "It is clear there is huge concern across the farming community. While the independent review is welcome, it cannot become a substitute for accountability. There was too much hiding behind a review in the Committee meeting.

“It was disappointing that many questions were met with references to the review rather than clear factual answers. That was particularly evident on issues surrounding the planning and execution of the operation, including the use of firearms. Where genuinely sensitive matters could not be discussed publicly, other options were available to allow the Committee to receive that evidence.

“It was also disappointing that neither the Chief Veterinary Officer nor the Permanent Secretary appeared before the Committee. The buck ultimately stops with the Department's most senior officials. Given the significance of this case, they should have been present, even remotely if necessary.

“This is about more than one individual farm. Northern Ireland's reputation for high animal welfare standards and food traceability depends on confidence in the regulators responsible for enforcing the law. Today's session demonstrated that confidence has been damaged. DAERA's credibility on animal welfare is on the line”.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice