Presbyterian Church in Ireland inappropriately shared 'intimate' information on ex-elder
The Presbyterian Church has committed to improving its legal compliance after it was found to have inappropriately shared information on an elder in a same-sex marriage.


Steven Smyrl was an elder at Christ Church Sandymount in Dublin but was dismissed by the Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI) in 2019 after entering a same-sex marriage with Roy Stanley.
During the investigation into his case, his local congregation submitted a letter of support to a six-minister investigating commission of the Dublin and Munster Presbytery, while Mr Smyrl also provided a detailed personal statement.
Mr Smyrl said had been assured his personal information would not be shared more widely.
However, during subsequent disciplinary investigations into his minister, Rev Katherine Meyer, he discovered that intimate information about him supplied during his own case had been circulated as part of the investigation into her. He subsequently saw internal correspondence referring to him and his husband as “sexually immoral people”.
Mr Smyrl lodged two complaints with the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC), both of which were upheld. PCI has accepted the findings and said it would improve its procedures.
Mr Smyrl told the News Letter: “The invasion of my privacy and the disclosure of deeply personal information without my consent has caused considerable distress and humiliation,” he said.
“The sensitive information concerned details of my intimate personal life."
He said the information was disclosed to members of the regional governing body and the leadership council of Christ Church Sandymount.
He became aware of the disclosure after seeing correspondence circulated to the Presbytery, confirming members had been exposed to the information. He later saw it in a letter sent to the minister and church council at his own church.
“The impact on both Roy and me has been profound,” he said, adding that the disclosure had left them feeling “exposed, humiliated and deeply violated”.
The breach was “particularly painful” he said, because it involved a church to which he had devoted much of his life and in which he had placed considerable trust.
The DPC concluded the Presbytery had failed to demonstrate a lawful basis under GDPR for further processing information on his personal data and was engaging with it about its data protection practices.
The Commission also said data controllers or processors may be liable for damages in court if they fail to observe their duty of care regarding personal data.
A PCI spokesperson said: “We acknowledge the outcome of the Data Protection Commission (Ireland) investigation, contained in a letter of 3 November 2026.
"We accept the decision of the Commission and in light of the findings, are committed to improving our processes and procedures, to ensure full compliance in the future.”
Mr Smyrl and Mr Stanley married in Dublin in 2018, shortly after PCI’s General Assembly voted to deny full church membership to anyone in a same-sex relationship.
In 2019, the Dublin and Munster Presbytery contacted Mr Smyrl after receiving images of him with Mr Stanley at their civil ceremony and in social settings.
Following a six-month investigation, it said his marriage was “not compatible with being in ordained leadership “and removed him as a ruling elder with immediate effect.
Mr Smyrl said he was now taking legal advice regarding redress for the harm caused by PCI’s handling of his information.