Presbyterian safeguarding crisis: Catholic abuse survivors wish they had similar probe 20 years ago

Survivors of clerical sex abuse in the Catholic Church say they wish they had seen the depth of investigation 20 years ago which is now being applied to abuse allegations in the Presbyterian Church.

Tony Gribben, who was abused by a Catholic priest and founded the Dromore Group representing survivors of clerical abuse across denominations.placeholder image
Tony Gribben, who was abused by a Catholic priest and founded the Dromore Group representing survivors of clerical abuse across denominations.

Tony Gribben, who was abused by a Catholic priest and founded the Dromore Group representing survivors of clerical abuse across denominations, shared that view with Belfast priest Fr Paddy McCafferty, who was also abused by a priest.

They were speaking a day after the PSNI updated its investigation into safeguarding concerns linked to the Presbyterian Church.

Ex-moderator Rev Trevor Gribben stepped down in November last year after a review found “serious and significant failings” in the church’s central safeguarding functions from 2009 to 2022.

The PSNI and Victim Support then held a televised press conference appealing for victims to come forward.

This week police reported that 168 people had contacted them to report concerns or provide information, a significant volume of documents was under review, two arrests had been made, 10 files submitted to the Public Prosecution Service and 10 voluntary interviews conducted.

Tony and Fr McCafferty say they wish there had been a similar public appeal for information and victims in 2005 when an explosive report in Ferns diocese uncovered allegations against 21 priests spanning four decades.

Questions were raised about whether similar abuse had occurred in NI. However, Freedom of Information investigations by this paper revealed the Catholic Church had agreed with the PSNI in 2005/06, that its archive of allegations dating back to 1965 would remain confidential. Instead, the church provided police with summaries.

Tony believes the PSNI were then occupied dealing with the Troubles’ legacy and building trust with the nationalist community. However, he says they should still have appealed publicly for abuse victims to come forward.

“I think they should have [made a public appeal], I think the chief constable at the time should have,” he told the News Letter.

Survivors are now pressing for a full public inquiry into the full scale of the abuse, which they believe should have followed the Ferns report in 2005.

“An independent group of experts put proposals for this inquiry to the First and Deputy First minister in July 2025, so it's well over a year ago,” he said.

“We are asking for an independent statutory inquiry, which would mean that independent experts would have access to all materials to determine the true scale of abuse that actually took place.”

Fr McCafferty said he had called for a similar investigation after Ferns in 2005.

“I remember at the time saying that there should be similar investigations in the north," he said. "This wasn't just a southern problem by any means.”

But he said there had been “nothing” – no public appeal or obvious major investigation.

The Executive Office was asked for an update the recommendations for a wider inquiry into clerical sex abuse.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice