Report finds 'no active decision' to give MLAs free car top-ups at Stormont - while charging the public
There was no “active decision” taken to provide free charging at a Stormont car park used by MLAs – with members of the public having to pay at another site in case they used it “purely to benefit from free charging” an Assembly report has found.
Some MLAs and Stormont staff charged their vehicles in a facility out of bounds to the public – prompting a public outcry over the fact they were already being paid for fuel.


A report into the debacle, brought to light by a BBC investigation, has found that authorities did not consider “the wider reputational implications of having two different payment arrangements within car parks controlled by the Assembly Commission”.
The probe found that when the free charger used by MLAs was installed, payment for using it was “prohibited under the terms of the grant until 2018”.
However, no payment system was introduced in subsequent years – including when an additional charger “was relocated from Hydebank where it was no longer required”.
The public was charged at another car park on the Stormont estate – but the review found that this “does not appear to have been the subject of a deliberate and considered decision in itself”.
Charging the public was “driven by two factors”, the report says. One was that the chargers were installed by the Department of Finance, and the other that there was “a rationale for requiring payment in the Lower East Car Park based on its circumstances”.
The report said: “As an open car park, there is less ability to control access and ensure that the charger was not being abused eg someone who was not visiting the building regularly coming to the car park purely to benefit from free charging.
“However, there does not appear to have been deliberate consideration in Facilities Management of the wider reputational implications of having two different payment arrangements within car parks controlled by the Assembly Commission. While this may not have introduced a change, there should have at least been such consideration”.
In July, the News Letter revealed the number of bookings made by each of the MLAs who availed of the free car chargers, while also getting paid travel expenses. This followed a Freedom of Information request by the Lisburn councillor Gary Hynds.
Assembly officials said MLAs Robbie Butler, Pam Cameron, Trevor Clarke and David Honeyford had used the free EV charging points from November 25 2025 to June 3 this year.
The assembly initially said it did not have such records, but later discovered them on a back system.
Top of the table was the DUP’s Ms Cameron. She made the most bookings among the politicians who used the free facility, with 58 slots on the assembly’s system.
In second place was the Ulster Unionist Mr Butler – with 49 slots in the six-month period. The Lagan Valley MLA had previously said he had “made occasional use of the charging facilities for partial charging”, but his “main vehicle charging is always done at home”.
Mr Butler also claimed that travel expenses are not a “direct repayment” of electricity costs.
Alliance MLA Mr Honeyford, his party’s consumer affairs spokesman, made 37 bookings to top up with free electricity.
Of the four whose use of the facility was on assembly records, the DUP’s Trevor Clarke had 32 charging slots.
A spokesperson for the Assembly Commission said: “The review has identified a number of areas for improvement in some of the internal processes and procedures surrounding the scheme. While the review considers that issues around the operation of the system arose from multiple decisions, assumptions and flaws in process, it has found that actions around the EV charging system were not taken in bad faith or with improper motives.
“The scheme was originally created on the basis of sound environmental objectives. Its arrangements reflected the circumstances and wider schemes that existed at the time when the charging points were introduced. However, the review identifies that the scheme should have been reviewed as the broader policy landscape evolved. It also clearly highlights that Members of the Assembly were not involved in taking any decisions on the introduction, development or implementation of the scheme.
“The Clerk/ Chief Executive has accepted the review's findings and has decided that its recommendations will be implemented in full. The recommendations relate to measures which will help strengthen governance, improve transparency and ensure that appropriate controls are in place going forward.
“In relation to the future operation of the scheme, significant decisions have already been taken by the Assembly Commission last June. The previous arrangements were suspended by the Clerk/ Chief Executive, and the Assembly Commission agreed that a fully paid charging model will be introduced for all electric vehicle charging facilities at Parliament Buildings. The new scheme is expected to be operational within the coming weeks.”