Transgenderism: 'Let people self-declare that they are legally male or female' says Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission

People who identify as transgender should to be allowed to legally switch from male to female (or vice-versa) on demand, the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has said.

The commission has called on Stormont's Department of Health to change the rules accordingly, and the department in turn has pledged to "consider" the report.

It follows years of rising opposition to self-ID across the UK, and comes the wake of the UK Supreme Court judgment which delivered a blow to the self-ID movement by defining “woman” as an adult who was born female, not merely anyone who self-identifies as such.

At present there are some required steps for gaining a formal gender-switch certificate – such as a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria – but the commission has indicated this should be replaced with a "self-declaration model".

The transgender flag flying in a demonstration; the NI Human Rights Commission has called for people to be allowed to 'self-declare' their official gender (Photo by MATTHIEU DELATY/Hans Lucas/AFP via Getty Images)placeholder image
The transgender flag flying in a demonstration; the NI Human Rights Commission has called for people to be allowed to 'self-declare' their official gender (Photo by MATTHIEU DELATY/Hans Lucas/AFP via Getty Images)

The commission’s call has come in for criticism from the pressure group Transgender Trend, which is opposed to children and young people becoming involved in transgenderism.

In addition, the commission's report also calls for the criminalisation of "conversion therapy", meaning attempts to alter someone's self-declared "gender identity" would be illegal.

The commission's push for gender self-ID comes despite the previous Tory government shelving its plans to do this UK-wide in 2020.

When the Scottish government attempted to introduce self-ID in 2023, the London government stepped in to halt that too.

The commission says that whilst the matter is "not listed as a reserved or excepted matter under the NI Act 1998", nonetheless "the law on gender recognition is a devolved matter".

Its annual report, published earlier this month, stated: "Eligibility criteria for a Gender Recognition Certificate require that an applicant is over 18, diagnosed with gender dysphoria, has lived in the acquired gender for more than two years and intends to do so permanently. The fee for a gender recognition certificate in NI is £6.

"It has been reported that people’s experiences of the gender recognition process in NI tend to be negative.

"Reflecting the Yogyakarta Principles, transgender representatives in NI consider the self-declaration model to be more appropriate."

The report goes on to recommend that "the Department of Health ensures that the gender recognition process in NI is amended to reflect the self-declaration model", adding: "This process should be affordable, respectful and accessible, including effectively training staff and professionals across an individual’s gender recognition journey."

Shelley Charlesworth of Transgender Trend has said "the UK's Supreme Court April 16 ruling made it clear that sex is binary, immutable and fixed at birth - having a certificate does not change that fact”, adding: “Self-ID particularly risky in health settings where clinicians must know the biological sex of patients to diagnose and prescribe.”

On "conversion therapy," the commission states that Stormont should “ban all conversion practices aimed at changing or suppressing a person’s sexual orientation, gender identity or gender expression, by any person or group of persons".

In doing so, the Department for Communities should be "guided" on the definition of conversion therapy by an “expert advisory panel” (made up largely of pro-transgender activist groups).

On this issue, Ms Charlesworth said: "Harmful practices to change a person's sexuality are already covered by the criminal law.

"We believe that a ban could prevent exploratory therapy for children and young people who have gender-related distress, and shut down holistic care for this vulnerable group which was recommended by the Cass Review."

In response to Transgender Trend, the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission told the News Letter: "The Commission’s Annual Statement sets out NI-specific international obligations and domestic context, which lead to recommendations on steps that should be taken to ensure human rights compliance.

"Our Annual Statement 2025 as reported provides our full recommendation on this issue."

The Department of Health said it “will carefully consider the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission’s annual report and its recommendations, including any implications for the health and social care system”.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice