Warning that resignation of BBC bosses won't fix its problems - as staff who 'oversaw the most egregious bias' remain

A group campaigning for the BBC to use accurate language on sex and gender says the resignation of the corporation’s director general and news chief executive won’t fix the issues damaging public trust in its reporting.

The campaign group SEEN in Journalism says that the reason given for Tim Davie and Deborah Turness resigning is “obscuring the need for a radical change in its approach” to reporting of the transgender issue and women’s rights.

Outgoing chief executive of BBC News, Deborah Turness, speaks to the media outside BBC Broadcasting House in London after her resignation. Photo: James Manning/PA Wireplaceholder image
Outgoing chief executive of BBC News, Deborah Turness, speaks to the media outside BBC Broadcasting House in London after her resignation. Photo: James Manning/PA Wire

It says journalists and editorial executives “who oversaw the most egregious bias” on trans issues for over a decade are still in place.

It comes as outgoing BBC News chief executive Deborah Turness says the reasons why impartiality failures on Trump, anti-semitism and women's rights weren’t dealt with “will emerge”.

She quit alongside Director General Tim Davie on Sunday, after sustained criticism following revelations in The Telegraph newspaper about a damning leaked dossier detailing a string of impartiality failings.

These included a misleading edit of a speech by President Trump and concerns over coverage of the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza.

The 19-page report by Michael Prescott – a former external adviser to the BBC’s editorial standards committee – also slammed the BBC’s coverage of women’s rights and transgender issues.

It alleged the broadcaster had been “captured by a small group of [staff] promoting the Stonewall view” on these issues, and that its LGBT news desk would “decline to cover any stories raising difficult questions” about trans ideology.

Stonewall is a lobby group, initially formed to campaign on gay rights, before shifting its focus to what it describes as “trans rights”.

These demands – such as for people to choose their own gender – clashed with sex-based equality laws, prompting a fierce debate largely ignored by the BBC until recently.

The lobby group advised the corporation on these issues – prompting accusations of bias. It eventually left a controversial ‘diversity scheme’ operated by Stonewall after a backlash from women’s and gay rights groups.

SEEN in Journalism – which represents journalists from a range of outlets including the BBC – says the broadcaster has “consistently and without exception taken a gender identity affirmative position across its content policies, story selection, contributor selection and language choices”.

“We know that the resignations of Tim Davies and Deborah Turness will not solve the problems highlighted by Michael Prescott's report. We are concerned that the putative central reason for the decisions of Tim Davie and Deborah Turness - the Trump-Panorama edit - is obscuring the need for a radical change in its approach to sex and gender, if public trust is to be restored.

“Most of those journalists and editorial executives who oversaw the most egregious bias on sex and gender over more than ten years are still in place.

“The new BBC leadership must continue the work that we know is already in its earliest stages of clawing back journalistic integrity on the issue.

“It must stop describing rapists as women: it must stem the flow of [transgender] affirmative content and start to cover the harm caused to women, children and LGB people, and it must get a grip on its 'diversity' campaigners who even this week are still promoting transgender activist events to its staff”.

Speaking to reporters as she arrived for work on Monday, Deborah Turness said it has been the privilege of her career to serve as CEO of BBC News “and to work with our brilliant team of journalists”.

“I stepped down over the weekend because the buck stops with me. But I'd like to make one thing very clear, BBC News is not institutionally biased. That's why it's the world's most trusted news provider”, she said.

Asked about comments from President Trump that BBC journalists are institutionally corrupt, the BBC chief said its journalists aren't corrupt, and are “hard working people who strive for impartiality” – saying she will stand by their journalism.

Asked about institutional bias – she said there was none.

Asked why mistakes on Trump, anti semitism and women's rights weren’t dealt with, she said: “I'm sure that story will emerge”.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice