We’ve no confidence in Muir, say farmers

​A prominent cattle farmer has heaped criticism upon the Farming Minister Andrew Muir over his and his party colleagues’ walk-out from the Assembly chamber yesterday.

​David Irwin from Redhouse Holsteins in the Benburb area was commenting after Mr Muir survived a vote of no confidence at Stormont after Sinn Fein declined to add its votes to the motion.

David Irwin has criticised the minister over his walk-outplaceholder image
David Irwin has criticised the minister over his walk-out

Mr Irwin said of the outcome: “I am disappointed but not surprised Alliance walked out.

“It re-emphasises the very reason the agricultural community has no confidence in Andrew Muir.

“Again I'm disappointed but not surprised the motion didn't go through – it's very obvious for all who have any idea of Northern Ireland's politics.

“The fact the parties couldn't come together on something that is as truly cross-community as not wanting to see healthy animals shot dead needlessly shows how sad a state our politics is in.”

Mr Irwin was among those circulating material online concerning the fuel protests in springtime, though he said he had no role in organising them.

Yesterday after the debate in Stormont, Redhouse Holsteins reposted a DUP statement reading: “Alliance arrogance on full display.

“Rather than stay in the Assembly and listen to the very real concerns of farmers, Andrew Muir and his Alliance colleagues chose to walk out.

“Farmers deserve to be heard – not walked out on.”

Even if a majority of MLAs had voted in favour of the no-confidence motion, it would not have been binding and the minister cannot be forced from office.

Speaking during the debate, People Before Profit MLA Gerry Carroll had said: “Despite the accusations thrown at the minister by the party to my right [the DUP], he has, in many ways, gone out of his way to accommodate and meet the demands of the UFU and the big agri-farmers, which is not the right approach.”

He said that “many in the environmental sector” would say that the minister is continuing with a policy of “appeasing the big farming lobby”.

For instance, Mr Carroll said: “There is still no independent environmental protection agency in the North; we are the only part of these islands without one."

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice