Stokes, Botham or Flintoff: Who is England’s greatest all-rounder?

Ben Stokes leaves the international stage having forged a reputation as one of England’s greatest all-rounders.

Here, the Press Association compares the departing Test captain to his illustrious predecessors Ian Botham and Andrew Flintoff.

Ben Stokes retired from international duty after England's series defeat to New Zealandplaceholder image
Ben Stokes retired from international duty after England's series defeat to New Zealand

Batting

Stokes played the most Tests of the three players – 122, compared to Botham’s 102 and just 79 for Flintoff – so it is no surprise he has scored by far the most runs with 7,273.

He also has the highest average at 34.47, while his 258 against South Africa in 2016 stands joint-15th on England’s list of highest individual scores.

Botham made 5,200 runs at 33.55 with a best of 208, matching Stokes’ tally of 14 hundreds – Stokes added 37 fifties to Botham’s 22.

Flintoff’s batting is remembered more for spectacular bursts of hitting than his overall weight of runs – he compiled 3,845 at an average of 31.78, with just five centuries but 26 fifties.

The Lancastrian does boast the highest strike rate of the three at 62.05, with Botham also above 60 despite playing at a time when scoring rates overall were slower than in recent years. Stokes, the on-field figurehead of the “Bazball” era, interestingly lags behind slightly in strike rate at 58.53.

Bowling

Botham stands out as comfortably the most productive bowler of the trio, taking over 50 per cent more wickets than Stokes despite playing 20 fewer Tests and bowling in 14 fewer innings.

Botham’s 383 scalps came at an average of 28.40 and included a pair of eight-wicket hauls at Lord’s, against Pakistan in 1978 and the West Indies in 1984.

He also took seven for 48 against India in 1980 and six wickets in an innings on seven occasions, most memorably at Headingley in the 1981 Ashes Test in which he then hit a match-turning 149 not out.

Six wickets represents Stokes’ best innings haul, on three occasions – twice against Australia before a career-best six for 22 against the West Indies in 2017.

He took 252 wickets overall at an average of 30.98, while Flintoff snared 226 at 32.79 with a best of five for 58 against the West Indies in 2004.

Botham’s dominance is clearly seen in his 27 five-wicket hauls, three times as many as Stokes and Flintoff combined and behind only James Anderson among all England bowlers. He was also the only one of the trio with a 10-wicket match to his name, achieving that feat on four occasions

All-round analysis

Botham and Stokes hit the all-rounder’s benchmark of having a higher batting than bowling average, Botham with a difference of over five runs and Stokes by 3.49. Flintoff missed out by a one-run margin.

All three rank among only 18 men in Test history with over 3,000 runs and 200 wickets to their name. Stokes and Botham are two of only four players with 5,000 runs and 250 wickets, along with South Africa’s Jacques Kallis and India’s Kapil Dev.

Stokes’ legacy is boosted by his captaincy, taking the reins for 44 games with 24 wins – and only two draws, testament to England’s aggressive approach on his and coach Brendon McCullum’s watch. Botham captained England on 12 occasions and Flintoff 11.

News you can trust since 1737
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice